intimation whatever that God was Father because He had begotten a Son. I fail to understand
what this argumentative and shrewdly professional reversal means.
But let us look to the thought in it below the words. ‘If God is Ungenerate because He
has begotten a Son, He was not Ungenerate before He begat Him.’ The answer to that is
plain; it consists in the simple statement of the Truth that ‘the word Father means both the
having begotten a Son, and also that the Begetter is not to be thought of as Himself coming
from any cause.’ If you look at the effect, the Person of the Son is revealed in the word
Father; if you look for a previous Cause, the absence of any beginning in the Begetter is
shown by that word. In saying that ‘Before He begat a Son, the Almighty was not Ungenerate,’
this pamphleteer lays himself open to a double charge; i.e. of misrepresentation of us, and
of insult to the Faith. He attacks, as if there was no mistake about it, something which our
Teacher never said, neither do we now assert, viz., that the Almighty became in process of
time a Father, having been something else before. Moreover in ridiculing the absurdity of
this fancied doctrine of ours, he proclaims his own wildness as to doctrine. Assuming that
the Almighty was once something else, and then by an advance became entitled to be called
Father, he would have it that before this He was not Ungenerate either, since Ungeneracy
is implied in the idea of Father. The folly of this hardly needs to be pointed out; it will be
abundantly clear to anyone who reflects. If the Almighty was something else before He be-
came Father, what will the champions of this theory say, if they were asked in what state
they propose to contemplate Him? What name are they going to give Him in that stage of
existence; child, infant, babe, or youth? Will they blush at such flagrant absurdity, and say
nothing like that, and concede that He was perfect from the first? Then how can He be
perfect, while as yet unable to become Father? Or will they not deprive Him of this power,
but say only that it was not fitting that there should be Fatherhood simultaneously with His
existence. But if it was not good nor fitting that He should be from the very beginning
Father of such a Son, how did He go on to acquire that which was not good?
But, as it is, it is good and fitting to God’s majesty that He should become Father of such
a Son. So they will make out that at the beginning He had no share in this good thing, and
as long as He did not have this Son they must assert (may God forgive me for saying it!)
that He had no Wisdom, nor Power, nor Truth, nor any of the other glories which from
various points of view the Only-begotten Son is and is called.
But let all this fall on the heads of those who started it. We will return whence we di-
gressed. He says, “if God is Father because of having begotten a Son, and if Father means
the being Ungenerate, then God was not this last, before He begat.” Now if he could speak
here as it is customary to speak about human life, where it is inconceivable that any should
acquire possession of many accomplishments all at once, instead of winning each of the
171
Several ways of controverting his quibbling syllogisms.