Chapter XII.
He proves from the renowned confession of the blessed Peter that Christ is God.
But if you prefer the authority of a greater person (although you ought not to slight the
authority of any one of either sex, on whom the confession of the mystery confers weight—for
whatever may be a person’s condition, or however humble his position, yet the value of his
faith is not thereby diminished) let us interrogate no beginner or untaught schoolboy, nor
a woman whose faith might perhaps appear to be but rudimentary; but that greatest of dis-
ciples among disciples, and of teachers among teachers, who presided and ruled over the
Roman Church, and held the chief place634 in the priesthood as he did in the faith. Tell us
then, tell us, we pray, O Peter, thou chief of Apostles, tell us how the Churches ought to
believe in God. For it is right that you should teach us, as you were taught by the Lord, and
that you should open to us the gate, of which you received the key. Shut out all those who
try to overthrow the heavenly house: and those who are endeavouring to enter by secret
holes and unlawful approaches: as it is clear that none can enter the gate of the kingdom
save one to whom the key bestowed on the Churches is revealed by you. Tell us then how
we ought to believe in Jesus Christ and to confess our common Lord. You will surely reply
without hesitation: “Why do you consult me as to the way in which the Lord should be
confessed, when you have before you my own confession of Him? Read the gospel, and you
will not want me myself, when you have got my confession. Nay, you have got me myself
when you have my confession; for though I have no weight apart from my confession, yet
the actual confession adds weight to my person.” Tell us then, O Evangelist, tell us the con-
fession: tell us the faith of the chief Apostle: did he confess that Jesus was only a man, or
God? did he say that there was nothing but flesh in Him, or did he proclaim Him the Son
of God? When then the Lord Jesus Christ asked whom the disciples believed and confessed
Him to be, Peter, the first of the Apostles, replied—one in the name of all—for the answer
of one was to the same effect as the faith of them all. But it was fitting that he should first
give the answer, that the order of the answer might correspond to the degree of honour:
and that he might outstrip them in confession, as he outstripped them in age. What then
570
does he say? “Thou art,” he says, “the Christ the Son of the living God.”635 I am obliged,
you heretic, to make use of a plain and simple question to confute you. Tell me, I pray, who
was He, to whom Peter gave that answer? You cannot deny that it was the Christ. I ask then,
what do you call Christ? man or God? Man certainly without any doubt: for hence springs
the whole of your heresy, because you deny that Christ is the Son of God. And so too you
say that Mary is Christotocos, but not Theotocos, because she was the mother of Christ, not
of God. Therefore you maintain, that Christ is only a man, and not God, and so that He is
634 Principatus.
635 S. Matt. xvi. 16.
Chapter XII. He proves from the renowned confession of the blessed Peter that Christ is God.
1433
Chapter XII. He proves from the renowned confession of the blessed Peter…