CHAP. VL] begotten AND UNBEGOTTEN, PIOW EELATIVES. 151
can be said to be begotten, except in relation to something.
For he is therefore a son, because begotten; and because a
son, therefore certainly begotten. And as is the relation of
son to father, so is the relation of the begotten to the begetter
;
and as is the relation of father to son, so is the relation of the
begetter to the begotten. And therefore any one is understood
to be a begetter under one notion, but understood to be unbe-
gotten under another. For though both are said of God the
Father, yet the former is said in relation to the begotten, that
is to the Son, which, indeed, they do not deny ; but that He is
called unbegotten, they declare to be said in respect to Himself.
They say then, If anything is said to be a father in respect to
itself, which cannot be said to be a son in respect to itself,
and whatever is said in respect to self is said according to
substance ; and He is said to be unbegotten in respect to Him-
self, which the Son cannot be said to be ; therefore He is said
to be unbegotten according to substance ; and because the Son
cannot be so said to be, therefore He is not of the same sub-
stance. This subtlety is to be answered by compelling them
to say themselves according towhat it is that the Son is equal
to the Father; whether according to that which is said in
relation to Himself, or according to that which is said in rela-
tion to the Father. For it is not according to that which is
said in relation to the Father, since in relation to the Father
He is said to be Son, and the Father is not Son, but Father.
Since Father and Son are not so called in relation to each
other in the same way as friends and neighbours are ; for a
friend is so called relatively to his friend, and if they love
each other equally, then the same friendship is in both ; and
a neighbour is so called relatively to a neighbour, and because
they are equally neighbours to each other (for each is neigh-
bour to the other, in the same degree as the other is neighbour
to him), there is the same neighbourhood in both. But because
the Son is not so called relatively to the Son, but to the Father,
it is not according to that which is said in relation to the
Father that the Son is equal to the Father; and it remains
that He is equal according to that which is said in relation to
Himself. But whatever is said in relation to self is said
according to substance : it remains therefore that He is equal