Canon IV.
(Greek.)
Bishop Gaudentius said: If it seems good to you, it is necessary to add to this decision
full of sincere charity which thou hast pronounced, that390 if any bishop be deposed by the
sentence of these neighbouring bishops, and assert that he has fresh matter in defence, a
new bishop be not settled in his see, unless the bishop of Rome judge and render a decision
as to this.
(Latin.)
Bishop Gaudentius said: It ought to be added, if it be your pleasure, to this sentence
full of sanctity which thou hast pronounced, that—when any bishop has been deposed by
the judgment of those bishops who have sees in neighbouring places, and he [the bishop
deposed] shall announce that his case is to be examined in the city of Rome—that no other
bishop shall in any wise be ordained to his see, after the appeal of him who is apparently
deposed, unless the case shall have been determined in the judgment of the Roman bishop.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon IV.
If a bishop has been deposed and affirms that he has an excuse to urge, unless Rome
has judged the case, no bishop shall be appointed in his room. For he might treat the decree
with scorn either through his nuncios or by his letters.
There are two distinct understandings of this canon. The one view is that the “neigh-
bours” of this canon are the same as the “neighbours” of the preceding canon (number iij.)
and that the meaning of this canon therefore is—If the court of second instance, correlating
of the bishops of the neighbouring province, has pronounced the accused guilty, he still has
one more appeal to a third court, viz., Rome. This is the view taken by the Greeks, Zonaras
419
and Balsamon, by the Ballerini, Van Espen, Palma, Walter, Natalis Alexander and many
others.
In direct opposition to this is the view that there is no third but only a second appeal
mentioned by the canon. The supporters of this interpretation are Peter de Marca, Tillemont,
Dupin, Fleury, Remi Ceillier, Neander, Stolberg, Echhorn, Kober, and with these Hefele
sides and states his reasons for doing so.
Hefele.
There must be added to the reasons of the connexion of this canon with the preceding,
the course of events, etc.:
1. That it certainly would be very curious if in the third canon mention was made of
the appeal to Rome as following the judgment of the court of first instance; in the fourth,
390 At this point begins the Greek text as given in Bev.
Canon IV.
767
Canon IV.