1848-9] CHARLOTTE BRONTE'S NOVELS 53
His house is full of brothers and brothers' families at present.
Mrs. White says it is never empty, for they have so many
family connections and so many intimate friends, and keep
up such constant warm intercourse with them, that they
are never without some of them, which all sounds very
nice.
The same to the same
16 GREAT ORMOND STREET, 5^ Dec. 1849.
So you like "Shirley" better than "Jane Eyre"; so
do I, in some points. In power and in descriptions of
scenery, there is nothing in " Shirley " which seems to me
to come up to some parts of " Jane Eyre," but then there
is nothing also in " Shirley " like the disagreeable parts of
"Jane Eyre." The book is infinitely more original and
full of character than the ordinary run of novels it
belongs quite to a higher class but it is also infinitely
below such as " Mary Barton " and " Deerbrook." * Caroline
and Mr. Helstone are thoroughly good characters. Shirley
and Mrs. Pryor are good ideas, but badly worked out the
rest seem to me all exaggerated Oh, Hortense Moore
should be excepted, she is good, too. The conversations
seem to me astonishingly poor ; here and there comes an
eloquent speech, as in Shirley's conversation with Mr.
Yorke, but the stiffness and dryness of the whole book,
its utter want of brilliancy of wit or humour, and the
unhappy tone of all the meditations, make it altogether
painful. That is not, however, so much to be wondered
at, when one knows that the author is herself threatened
with consumption at this time, and has lost her two sisters,
Ellis and Acton Bell, by it. Their real name is Bronte,
they are of the Nelson family.
1
By Harriet Martineau.