fection of our discerning. It does not follow that there are properly two sorts of saints, because
some who are not real saints, do by the show and appearance they make obtain the name
of saints, and are reputed such, and whom by the rules of Scripture (which are accommodated
to our imperfect state) we are directed to receive and treat as saints; any more than it follows
that there are two sorts of honest men, because some who are not truly honest men, yet being
so seemingly or visibly, do obtain the name of honest men, and ought to be treated by us as
such. So there are not properly two distinct churches of Christ, on the real, and another the
visible; though they that are visibly or seemingly of the one only church of Christ, are many
more than they who are really of his church; and so the visible or seeming church is of larger
extent than the real.
Visibility is a relative thing, and has relation to an eye that views or beholds. Visibility
is the same as appearance or exhibition to the eye; and to be a visible saint is the same as to
appear to be a real saint in the eye that beholds; not the eye of God, but the eye of man. Real
saints or converts are those that are so in the eye of God; visible saints or converts are those
who are so in the eye of man; not his bodily eye, for thus no man is a saint any more in the
eye of a man than he is in the eye of a beast; but the eye of his mind, which is his judgment
or esteem. There is no more visibility of holiness in the brightest professor to the eye of our
bodies, without the exercise of the reason and judgment of our minds, than may be in a
machine. But nothing short of an apparent probability, or a probable exhibition, can amount
to a visibility to the eye of man’s reason or judgment. The eye which God has given to man
is the eye of reason: and the eye of a Christianis reason sanctified, regulated, and enlightened,
by a principle of christian love. But it implies a contradiction to say, that that is visible to
the eye of reason, which does not appear probable to reason. And if there be a man that is
in the sense a visible saint, he is in the eye of a rational judgment a real saint. To say a man
is visibly a saint, but not visibly a real saint, but only visibly a visible saint, is a very absurd
way of speaking; it is as much as to say, he is to appearance an appearing saint; which is in
effect to say nothing, and to use words without signification. The thing which must be visible
and probable, in order to visible saintship, must be saintship itself, or real grace and true
holiness; not visibility of saintship, not unregenerate morality, not mere moral sincerity. To
pretend, or in any respect to exhibit, moral sincerity, makes nothing visible beyond what is
pretended to or exhibited. For a man to have that visibly, which if he had it really, and have
nothing more, would not make him a real saint, is not to be visibly a saint.
Mr. Stoddard, in his Appeal to the Learned, seems to express the very same notion of
visibility, and that visibility of saintship which is requisite to persons coming to the Lord’s
supper, that I have here expressed. In page 10, he makes a distinction between being visibly
circumcised in heart, and being really so; evidently meaning by the latter, saving conversion;
and he allows the former, viz. a visibility of heart-circumcision, to be necessary to a coming
to the Lord’s supper. So that according to him, it is not a visibility of moral sincerity only,
1756
SECTION I. Church members should be visible saints.