426
thereby a pattern of concord and patience, that we should not pertinaciously love our own
opinions, but should rather account as our own any true and rightful suggestions of our
brethren and colleagues for the common health and weal."1212 Here is a passage in which
Cyprian records what we also learn in holy Scripture, that the Apostle Peter, in whom the
primacy of the apostles shines with such exceeding grace, was corrected by the later Apostle
Paul, when he adopted a custom in the matter of circumcision at variance with the demands
of truth. If it was therefore possible for Peter in some point to walk not uprightly according
to the truth of the gospel, so as to compel the Gentiles to judaize, as Paul writes in that epistle
in which he calls God to witness that he does not lie; for he says, "Now the things which I
write unto you, behold, before God, I lie not;"1213 and, after this sacred and awful calling of
God to witness, he told the whole tale, saying in the course of it, "But when I saw that they
walked not uprightly, according to the truth of the gospel, I said unto Peter before them all,
If thou, being a Jew, livest after the manner of the Gentiles, and not as do the Jews, why
compellest thou the Gentiles to live as do the Jews?"1214—if Peter, I say, could compel the
Gentiles to live after the manner of the Jews, contrary to the rule of truth which the Church
afterwards held, why might not Cyprian, in opposition to the rule of faith which the whole
Church afterwards held, compel heretics and schismatics to be baptized afresh? I suppose
that there is no slight to Cyprian in comparing him with Peter in respect to his crown of
martyrdom; rather I ought to be afraid lest I am showing disrespect towards Peter. For who
can be ignorant that the primacy of his apostleship is to be preferred to any episcopate
whatever? But, granting the difference in the dignity of their sees, yet they have the same
glory in their martyrdom. And whether it may be the case that the hearts of those who
confess and die for the true faith in the unity of charity take precedence of each other in
different points, the Lord Himself will know, by the hidden and wondrous dispensation of
whose grace the thief hanging on the cross once for all confesses Him, and is sent on the
selfsame day to paradise,1215 while Peter, the follower of our Lord, denies Him thrice, and
has his crown postponed:1216 for us it were rash to form a judgment from the evidence.
But if any one were now found compelling a man to be circumcised after the Jewish fashion,
as a necessary preliminary for baptism, this would meet with much more general repudiation
by mankind, than if a man should be compelled to be baptized again. Wherefore, if Peter,
on doing this, is corrected by his later colleague Paul, and is yet preserved by the bond of
peace and unity till he is promoted to martyrdom, how much more readily and constantly
1212 Cypr. Ep. lxxi.
1213 Gal. i. 20.
1214 Gal. ii. 14.
1215 Luke xxiii. 40-43.
1216 Matt. xxvi. 69-75.
730
Chapter 1