162 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK V.
He is. Does the Holy Spirit proceed always, and proceed
not in time, but from eternity, but because He so proceeded
that He was capable of being given, was already a gift even
before there was one to whom He might be given ? For there
is a difference in meaning between a gift and a thing that has
been given. For a gift may exist even before it is given
;
but it cannot be called a thing that has been given unless it
has been given.
Chap. xvi.—What is said ofGod in time, is said relatively, not accidentally.
1 7. Nor let it trouble us that the Holy Spirit, although He
is co-eternal with the Father and the Son, yet is called some-
thing which exists in time ; as, for instance, this very thing
which we have called Him, a thing that has been given. For
the Spirit is a gift eternally, but a thing that has been given in
time. For if a lord also is not so called unless when he begins
to have a slave, that appellation likewise is relative and in time
to God ; for the creature is not from all eternity, of which He
is the Lord. How then shall we make it good that relative
terms themselves are not accidental, since nothing happens ac-
cidentally to God in time, becauseHe is incapable of change, as
we have argued in the beginning of this discussion ? Behold !
to be the Lord is not eternal to God ; otherwise we should be
compelled to say that the creature also is from eternity, since
He would not bear rule from all eternity unless the creature
also was a servant from all eternity. But as he cannot be a
slave who has not a lord, neither can he be a lord who has not
a slave. And if there be any one who says that God, indeed,
is alone eternal, and that times are not eternal on account of
their variety and changeableness, but that times nevertheless
did not begin to be in time (for there was no time before times
began, and therefore it did not happen to God in time that He
should be Lord, since He was Lord of the very times them-
selves, which assuredly did not begin in time) : what will he
reply respecting man, who was made in time, and of whom
assuredly He was not the Lord before he w^as of whom He
was to be Lord ? Certainly to be the Lord of man happened
to God in time. And that all dispute may seem to be taken
away, certainly to be your Lord, or mine, who have only lately