epistle to Euphration he dwells upon the subordination of the Son and approves the Arian
opinion, which he had defended also in the other epistle, that the “Father was before the
Son.” The expression, “not true God” (a very common Arian expression; see Athan. Orat.
16
c. Arian. I. 6) seems therefore to have been used by Eusebius to express a belief, not that the
Son did not possess real divinity (as the genuine Arians used it), but that he was not equal
to the Father, who, to Eusebius’ thought, was “true God.” He indeed expressly calls the Son
θεός, which shows—when the sense in which he elsewhere uses the word is considered—that
he certainly did believe him to partake of Godhood, though, in some mysterious way, in a
smaller degree, or in a less complete manner than the Father. That Eusebius misunderstood
Arius, and did not perceive that he actually denied all real deity to the Son, was due doubtless
in part to his lack of theological insight (Eusebius was never a great theologian), in part to
his habitual dread of Sabellianism (of which Arius had accused Alexander, and toward which
Eusebius evidently thought that the latter was tending), which led him to look with great
favor upon the pronounced subordinationism of Arius, and thus to overlook the dangerous
extreme to which Arius carried that subordinationism.
We are now, the writer hopes, prepared to admit that Eusebius, after the breaking out
of the Arian controversy, became an Arian, as he understood Arianism, and supported that
party with considerable vigor; and that not as a result of mere personal friendship, but of
theological conviction. At the same time, he was then, as always, a peace-loving man, and
while lending Arius his approval and support, he united with other Palestinian bishops in
enjoining upon him submission to his bishop (Sozomen, H. E. I. 15). As an Arian, then, and
yet possessed with the desire of securing, if it were possible, peace and harmony between
the two factions, Eusebius appeared at the Council of Nicæa, and there signed a creed con-
taining Athanasian doctrine and anathematizing the chief tenets of Arius. How are we to
explain his conduct? We shall, perhaps, do best to let him explain his own conduct. In his
letter to the church of Cæsarea (preserved by Socrates, H. E. I. 8, as well as by other authors),
he writes as follows:—
“What was transacted concerning ecclesiastical faith at the Great Council assembled at
Nicæa you have probably learned, Beloved, from other sources, rumour being wont to precede
the accurate account of what is doing. But lest in such reports the circumstances of the case
have been misrepresented, we have been obliged to transmit to you, first, the formula of
faith presented by ourselves; and next, the second, which the Fathers put forth with some
additions to our words. Our own paper, then, which was read in the presence of our most
pious Emperor, and declared to be good and unexceptionable, ran thus:—
“‘As we have received from the Bishops who preceded us, and in our first catechisings,
and when we received the Holy Laver, and as we have learned from the divine Scriptures,
and as we believed and taught in the presbytery, and in the Episcopate itself, so believing
also at the time present, we report to you our faith, and it is this:—
26
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.