bear the contradictions both of reason and faith which must follow? In the first place, if this
were true, we should seem to have no reason for mourning over those who have departed
from the body without that grace, and there would be no ground for being solicitous and
using urgent exhortation that men would accept the grace of God before they die, lest they
should be punished with eternal death. If, again, it be alleged that in hell those only believe
to no purpose and in vain who refused to accept here on earth the gospel preached to them,
but that believing will profit those who never despised a gospel which they never had it in
their power to hear another still more absurd consequence is involved, namely, that for-
asmuch as all men shall certainly die, and ought to come to hell wholly free from the guilt
of having despised the gospel; since otherwise it can be of no use to them to believe it when
they come there, the gospel ought not to be preached on earth, a sentiment not less foolish
than profane.
Chap. V.
14. Wherefore let us most firmly hold that which faith, resting on authority established
beyond all question, maintains: “that Christ died according to the Scriptures,” and that “He
was buried,” and that “He rose again the third day according to the Scriptures,” and all
other things which have been written concerning Him in records fully demonstrated to be
true. Among these doctrines we include the doctrine that He was in hell, and, having loosed
the pains of hell, in which it was impossible for Him to be holden, from which also He is
with good ground believed to have loosed and delivered whom He would, He took again to
Himself that body which He had left on the cross, and which had been laid in the tomb.
These things, I say, let us firmly hold; but as to the question propounded by you from the
words of the Apostle Peter, since you now perceive the difficulties which I find in it, and
since other difficulties may possibly be found if the subject be more carefully studied, let us
continue to investigate it, whether by applying our own thoughts to the subject, or by asking
the opinion of any one whom it may be becoming and possible to consult.
15. Consider, however, I pray you, whether all that the Apostle Peter says concerning
spirits shut up in prison, who were unbelieving in the days of Noah, may not after all have
been written without any reference to hell, but rather to those times the typical character
of which he has transferred to the present time. For that transaction had been typical of future
events, so that those who do not believe the gospel in our age, when the Church is being
built up in all nations, may be understood to be like those who did not believe in that age
while the ark was a preparing; also, that those who have believed and are saved by baptism
may be compared to those who at that time, being in the ark, were saved by water; wherefore
he says, “So baptism by a like figure saves you.” Let us therefore interpret the rest of the
statements concerning them that believed not so as to harmonise with the analogy of the
figure, and refuse to entertain the thought that the gospel was once preached, or is even to
1107
To Evodius