OBJECT. IX.
If sanctifying grace be requisite to a due approach to the Lord’s table, then no man may
come but he that knows he has such grace. A man must not only think he has a right to the
Lord’s supper, in order to his lawful partaking of it; but he must know he has a right. If
nothing but sanctification gives him a real right to the Lord’s supper, then nothing short of
the knowledge of sanctification gives him a known right to it: only an opinion and probable
hopes of a right will not warrant his coming.
Answ. 1. I desire those who insist on this as an invincible argument, to consider calmly
whether they themselves ever did, or ever will, stand to it. For here these two things are to
be observed:
(1.) If no man may warrantably come to the Lord’s supper, but such as know they have
a right, then no unconverted persons may come unless they not only think, but know, it is
the mind of God, that unconverted persons should come, and know that he does not require
grace in order to their coming. For unless they know that men may come without grace,
they cannot know that they themselves have a right to come, being without grace. And will
any one assert and stand to it, that of necessity all adult persons, of every age, rank, and
condition of life, must be so versed in this controversy, as to have a certainty in this matter,
in order to their coming to the Lord’s supper? It would he most absurd for any to assert it
to be a point of easy proof, the evidence of which is so clear and obvious to every one of
every capacity, as to supersede all occasion for their being studied in divinity, in order to a
certainty of its truth, that persons may come to the sacred table of the Lord, notwithstanding
they know themselves to be unconverted! Especially considering, that the contrary to this
opinion has been in general the judgment of protestant divines and churches, from the Re-
formation to this day; and that the most of the greatest divines that have ever appeared in
the world, who have spent their lives in the diligent prayerful study of divinity, have been
fixed in the reverse of that opinion. This is sufficient at least to show, that this opinion is
not so plain as not to be a disputable point; and that the evidence of it is not so obvious to
persons of the lowest capacity and little inquiry, as that all may come to a certainty in the
matter, without difficulty and without study. I would humbly ask here, What has been the
case in fact in our churches, who have practised for so many years on this principle? Can it
be pretended, or was it ever supposed, that the communicants in general, even persons of
mean intellects and low education, not excepting the very boys and girls of sixteen years
old, that have been taken into the church, had so studied divinity, as not only to think, but
know, that our pious forefathers, and almost all the protestant and christian divines in the
world, have been in an error in this matter? And have people ever been taught the necessity
of this previous knowledge? Has it ever been insisted upon, that before persons come to the
Lord’s supper, they must look so far into the case of a right to the Lord’s supper, as to come
not only to a full settled opinion, but even certainty, in this point? And has any one minister
OBJ. IX. If grace be required, it must be known.
1849
OBJ. IX. If grace be required, it must be known.