mitigating circumstance.3042 In all historical candor it looks as if there had been some gen-
eral intrigue against Constantine which had been met in this way; but the fairest verdict to
enter is “causes unknown.”
In estimating the characteristic value of the acts it must be noted, 1. That it has in no
sense the character of private execution. The emperor was judge. Even if he mistook evidence
and put to death an innocent man, it was as when a judge does the same. 2. That the relative
moral character of punishments inflicted is conditioned by the custom of punishment. An
English judge of the past was not as cruel in hanging a man for theft, as a modern one in
applying the extreme penalty of the law to an offense with mitigating circumstances, would
be. 3. That all law of evidence, all rhyme and reason, says that any man’s any act is to be in-
terpreted in the light of his general character. Where evidence is lacking or doubtful, such
evidence of general character has actual weight, and may be conclusive. In application to
these acts note (a) The peculiar forbearance which Constantine exercised toward Maximian.
(b) The conclusive universal testimony to the general mildness of his character and his ha-
bitual mercifulness. In view of this, it is to be judged that there was some real, or appearing,
great ground of judicial wrath. 4. That Constantine had suffered from plots on the part of
his own relatives over and over again, and spared, and been plotted against again, as in the
cases of Maximian, Bassianus, and Licinius. 5. That they were not put to death “in a gust of
passion” at once, but in successive acts. In view of these things it is fair and just to say that
they were put to death on grounds which seemed just and for the welfare of society, and
their deaths in no sense indicate cruelty or unnaturalness on the part of Constantine. Even
the death of Licinius must be interpreted by the political ethics of the times and its circum-
stances. So long as sentimentalists continue to send bouquets to murderers and erect
monuments to anarchists, they will regard execution, even legal execution, as prima facie
evidence of cruelty, and the killing of a murderer in self-defense, or the hanging of a traitor,
as crime. Constantine’s whole character ensures that if he thought he could have spared
them, or any one, with safety, he would have done so.3043
In general he was a faithful husband as respects marital virtue, and a good father. He
took care that his children should be well educated. Crispus was under Lactantius (Hieron.),
and the others perhaps under Arborius (“Auson. de Prof. Burdig. 16”); at all events, he had
3042 Seeck (Ztschr. f. wiss. Theol. 1890, p. 73) maintains that it is established (“urkundlich fest”) that Licinius
was still living in 336, in which case he would have been more than twenty years old. He maintains also that he
was not the son of Constantine, but the illegitimate son of Licinius by a slave woman.
3043 On this question compare especially monographs of Görres and Seeck. See under Literature, where
other titles, e.g. Hug and Wegnerus, will also be found. In general, the remark of Ludermann (Lipsius, Theol.
Jahrb. 1886, p. 108) is valid, “The arguments against Constantine’s Christianity, which are drawn from his
moral character, have ever been the weakest.”
1072
Moral Characteristics.