man.” Again we ask what necessity there is to draw this conclusion from his previous re-
marks? I do not see that it is proved any more 138because the energies vary amongst them-
selves as much as the works do, and because the works are not all from the same source but
are stated by him to come from different sources. As for the heavens and each angel, star,
and man, or anything else understood by the word “creation,” we know from Scripture that
they are all the work of One: whereas in their system of theology the Son and the Spirit are
not the work of one and the same, the Son being the work of the energy which ‘follows’ the
first Being, and the Spirit the further work of that work. What the connexion, then, is between
that statement and the heavens, man, angel, star, which he drags in, must be revealed by
himself, or some one whom he has initiated into his profound philosophy. The blasphemy
66
intended by his words is plain enough, but the way the profanity is stated is inconsistent
with itself. To suppose that within the Holy Trinity there is a difference as wide as that which
we can observe between the heavens which envelope the whole creation, and one single man
or the star which shines in them, is openly profane: but still the connexion of such thoughts
and the pertinence of such a comparison is a mystery to me, and I suspect also to its author
himself. If indeed his account of the creation were of this sort, viz., that while the heavens
were the work of some transcendent energy each star in them was the result of an energy
accompanying the heavens, and that then an angel was the result of that star, and a man of
that angel, his argument would then have consisted in a comparison of similar processes,
and might have somewhat confirmed his doctrine. But since he grants that it was all made
by One (unless he wishes to contradict Scripture downright), while he describes the produc-
tion of the Persons after a different fashion, what connexion is there between this newly
imported view and what went before?
But let it be granted to him that this comparison does have some connexion with
proving variation amongst the Beings (for this is what he desires to establish); still let us see
how that which follows hangs on to what he has just said, ‘In proportion as one work is
prior to another and more precious than it, so would a pious mind affirm that one energy
transcends another.’ If in this he alludes to the sensible world, the statement is a long way
from the matter in hand. There is no necessity whatever that requires one whose subject is
theological to philosophize about the order in which the different results achieved in the
world-making are to come, and to lay down that the energies of the Creator are higher and
lower analogously to the magnitude of each thing then made. But if he speaks of the Persons
themselves, and means by works that are ‘older and more honourable’ those ‘works’ which
he has just fashioned in his own creed, that is, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, it would be
perhaps better to pass over in silence such an abominable view, than to create even the ap-
pearance of its being an argument by entangling ourselves with it. For can a ‘more honour-
138 τῷ παρηλλάχθαι, κ.τ.λ. This is Oehler’s emendation for the faulty reading τὸ of the editions.
124
His elaborate account of degrees and differences in 'works' and 'energies'…