18. But some one on the opposite side says, How do we know whether the theologians
have written what is certain and well known, or set forth a wanton fiction,4172 as they thought
and judged? That has nothing to do with the matter; nor does the reasonableness of your
argument depend upon this,—whether the facts are as the writings of the theologians state,
or are otherwise and markedly different. For to us it is enough to speak of things which
come before the public; and we need not inquire what is true, but only confute and disprove
that which lies open to all, and which men’s thoughts have generally received. But if they
are liars, declare yourselves what is the truth, and disclose the unassailable mystery. And
how can it be done when the services of men of letters are set aside? For what is there which
can be said about the immortal gods that has not reached men’s thoughts from what has
been written by men on these subjects?4173 Or can you relate anything yourselves about
their rights and ceremonies, which has not been recorded in books, and made known by
what authors have written? Or if you think these of no importance, let all the books be des-
troyed which have been composed about the gods for you by theologians, pontiffs, and even
some devoted to the study of philosophy; nay, let us rather suppose that from the foundation
of the world no man ever wrote4174 anything about the gods: we wish to find out, and desire
to know, whether you can mutter or murmur in mentioning the gods,4175 or conceive those
in thought to whom no idea4176 from any book gave shape in your minds. But when it is
clear that you have been informed of their names and powers by the suggestions of books,4177
it is unjust to deny the reliableness of these books by whose testimony and authority you
establish what you say.
4172 So all the edd., though Orelli approves of fictione (edd. -em), which is, he says, the ms. reading, “set forth
with wanton fiction.”
4173 The ms. and earlier edd., with Hild. and Oehler, read ex hominum de scriptis; LB. and Orelli inserting
his after de, as above.
4174 The ms. and both Roman edd. read esse, which is clearly corrupt; for which LB. gives scripsisse(misprinted
scripse), as above.
4175 i.e., “speak of them at all.”
4176 Lit., “an idea of no writing.”
4177 Lit., “been informed by books suggesting to you,” etc.
Chapter XVIII.
1150
Chapter XVIII.