SECT. II.
Concerning the kind of death, threatened to our first parents, if they should eat of the
forbidden fruit.
Dr. T. in his observations on the three first chapters of Genesis says, (p. 7.) “The
threatening to man in case of transgression was, that he should surely die.—Death is the
losing of life. Death is opposed to life, and must be understood according to the nature of
that life, to which it is opposed. Now the death here threatened can, with any certainty, be
opposed only to the life God gave Adam, when he created him, ( ver. 7.) Any thing besides
this must be pure conjecture, without solid foundation.”
To this I would say; it is true, Death it opposed to life, and must be understood according
to the nature of that life, to which it is opposed. But does it therefore follow, that nothing can
be meant by it but the loss of life? Misery is opposed to happiness, and sorrow is in Scripture
often opposed to joy; but can we conclude from thence, that nothing is meant in Scripture
181
by sorrow, but the loss of joy? or that there is no more in misery, than the loss or absence
of happiness? And if the death threatened to Adam can, with certainty, be opposed only to
the life given to Adam, when God created him; I think, a state of perfect, perpetual, and
hopeless misery is properly opposed to that state Adam was in, when God created him. For
I suppose it will not be denied, that the life Adam had, was truly a happy life; happy in perfect
innocency, in the favour of his Maker, surrounded with the happy fruits and testimonies of
his love. And I think it has been proved, that he also was happy in a state of perfect right-
eousness. Nothing is more manifest, than that it is agreeable to a very common acceptation
of the word life, in Scripture, that it be understood as signifying a state of excellent and
happy existence. Now that which is most opposite to that life and state in which Adam was
created, is a state of total, confirmed wickedness, and perfect hopeless misery, under the
divine displeasure and curse; not excluding temporal death, or the destruction of the body,
as an introduction to it.
Besides, that which is much more evident, than any thing Dr. T. says on this head, is,
that the death which was to come on Adam, as the punishment of his disobedience, was op-
posed to that life, which he would have had as the reward of his obedience in case he had
not sinned. Obedience and disobedience are contraries; the threatenings and promises which
are sanctions of a law, are set in direct opposition; and the promises, rewards, and threatened
punishments, are most properly taken as each others’ opposites. But none will deny, that
the life which would have been Adam’s reward, if he had persisted in obedience, was eternal
life. And therefore we argue justly that the death which stands opposed to that life, (Dr. T.
himself being judge, p. 120. S.) is manifestly eternal death, a death widely different from the
death we now die—to use his own words. If Adam, for his persevering obedience, was to
have had everlasting life and happiness, in perfect holiness, union with his Maker, and enjoy-
ment of his favour, and this was the life which was to be confirmed by the tree of life; then,
SECTION II. Death threatened to our first parents.
1031
SECTION II. Death threatened to our first parents.