Elucidations.
————————————
I.
(We here behold only shadows, etc., p. 335.)
Schleiermacher,2821 in commenting on Plato’s Symposium, remarks: “Even natural birth
(i.e., in Plato’s system) was nothing but a reproduction of the same eternal form and
idea.…The whole discussion displays the gradation, not only from that pleasure which arises
from the contemplation of personal beauty through that which every larger object, whether
single or manifold, may occasion, to that immediate pleasure of which the source is in the
Eternal Beauty,” etc. Our author ennobles such theorizing by mounting up to the great I
Am.
II.
(Christ Himself is the one who is born, p. 337.)
Wordsworth, and many others of the learned, sustain our author’s comment on this
passage.2822 So Aquinas, ad loc., Bede, and many others. Methodius is incorrectly represented
as rejecting2823 the idea that “the woman” is the Blessed Virgin Mary, for no such idea existed
for him to reject. He rejects the idea that the man-child is Christ; but that idea was connected
with the supposition that the woman was the Church of the Hebrews bringing forth the
Messiah. Gregory the Great regards the woman as the Christian Church. So Hippolytus:2824
“By the woman…is meant most manifestly the Church, endued with the Father’s Word,
whose brightness is above the sun,” etc. Bossuet says candidly,2825 “C’est l’Église, tout
éclatante de la lumière de J. C.,” etc.
Now, note the progress of corruption, one fable engendering another. The text of Gen.
iii. 15, contrary to the Hebrew, the Seventy, the Syriac, and the Vulgate itself, in the best
mss., is made to read, “She shall bruise thy head,” etc. The “woman,” therefore, becomes the
Mother of our Lord, and the “great red dragon” (of verse 3), from which the woman “fled
into the wilderness,” is next represented as under her feet (where the moon appears in the
sacred narrative); and then the Immaculate Conception of her Holy Seed is transferred back
to the mother of Mary, who is indecently discussed, and affirmed to have been blest with
an “Immaculate Conception” when, in the ordinary process of nature, she was made the
mother of the Virgin. So, then, the bull Ineffabilis—comes forth, eighteen hundred years
after the event,2826 with the announcement that what thousands of saints and many bishops
2821 Introduction to the Dialogues, etc., Dobson’s translation, Cambridge, 1836.
2822 See his work On the Apocalypse, Lecture IX. p. 198, ed. Philadelphia, 1852.
2823 Speaker’s Com., ad loc.
2824 Vol. v. p. 217, this series.
2825 Works, vol. i. p. 447, ed. Paris, 1845.
2826 Dec. 8, 1854.
Elucidations.
808
Elucidations.