matters as upon schism. He would rather leave the archives and elucidate the doctrine, in
which he claims to have the book of the world; that the Catholics are the Lord’s inheritance;
that they stand in fellowship with the churches of the New Testament; they are the light of
the world. A divine rebuke has befallen Donatism in all the tenets of its particularity, by
the schism and return of the Maximianists.
No open door was passed by. On a journey to Cirta, possibly about the beginning of
398 A.D., he visited with clerical friends the aged Donatist, bishop Fortunius, at Tibursi.
A great company gathered who interrupted the debate; all attempts at taking notes were fi-
nally given up. In a letter (Ep. xliv.) to the Donatists, Eleusius, Glorius, and the two Felixes,
who were of the number of those addressed in the previous epistle, he speaks of their witness
to the conciliatory disposition of Fortunius, and recounts the substance of the interview,
with the desire that it may be submitted to that bishop for correction. The discussion had
opened with the question of the Church. Fortunius regretted that Augustin was not in it;
the latter reversed the wish. What is the Church? Is it diffused throughout the whole world,
or is it confined to Africa? Can the Donatists send letters of communion to any of the
apostolic churches? Thence they dissected the Donatist claim to be the people of God, on
account of their subjection to persecution; in which it appears that they recorded the schism
of the whole world from themselves as the true Church as due to sympathy with the Macarian
persecution; up to that time they had held fellowship with the whole world, and as proof
thereof brought forward a letter of a council of Sardica addressed to them. From the con-
demnation of Athanasius and Julius by this document, Augustin, to whom it was new,
concluded that this was an Arian council, and was only the more damaging to their theory.
The note of persecution being resumed, he maintained that there was no approved suffering
unless for a just cause, and hence the justice of the cause must first be established. Though
Ambrose had endured violence at the hand of the soldiery, they would deny him to be a
Christian, for they would rebaptize even him. Maximianists on the other hand were confessed
to be just, although they had been dispossessed of their basilicas by the Primianist appeal
to the state. As an offset, Fortunius urged the curious fact that before the election of Ma-
jorinus, an interventor had been chosen, whom the Cæcilianists put out of the way. On the
following day Augustin had to confess that there was no example in the New Testament to
justify compulsion in matters of faith. The next topic was Discipline. Augustin pleaded for
toleration in order to keep unity. A point as to Johannic baptism sprang up, but was not
pressed. From this time the debate became miscellaneous and repetitious; in its progress
Fortunius confessed reluctantly that rebaptism was a fixed practice among them, and that
even a Catholic bishop so highly esteemed among the Donatists for his non-persecuting
654
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.