experiences, or an obscurity in the order and method of his experiences, &c. The minister
in receiving him to the communion of the church, is to act as a public officer, and in behalf
of the public society, and not merely for himself, and therefore is to be governed, in acting,
by a proper visibility of godliness in the eye of the public.
It is not my design, in holding the negative of the foregoing question, to affirm, that all
who are regularly admitted as members of the visible church in complete standing, ought
to be believed to be godly or gracious persons, when taken collectively, or considered in the
gross, by the judgment of any person or society. This may not be, and yet each person taken
singly may visibly be a gracious person to the eye of the judgment of Christians in general.
These two are not the same thing, but vastly diverse; and the latter maybe, and yet not the
former. If we should know so much of a thousand persons one after another, and from what
we observed in them should have a prevailing opinion concerning each one of them, singly
taken, that they were indeed pious, and think the judgment we passed, when we consider
each judgment apart, to be right; it will not follow, when we consider the whole company
collectively, that we shall have so high an opinion of our own judgment, as to think it
probable, there was not one erroneous judgment in the whole thousand. We all have innu-
merable judgments about one thing or other, concerning religious, moral, secular, and
philosophical affairs, concerning past, present, and future matters, reports, facts, persons,
things, &c. And concerning all the many thousand dictates of judgment that we have, we
think them every one right, taken singly; for if there was any one that we thought wrong, it
would not be our judgment; and yet there is no man, unless he is stupidly foolish, who when
he considers all in the gross, will say he thinks that his every opinion he is of, concerning
all persons and things whatsoever, important and trifling, is right, without the least error.
But the more clearly to illustrate this matter, as it related to visibility, or probable appearances
of holiness in professors: supposing it had been found by experience concerning precious
stones, that such and such external marks were probable signs of a diamond; and supposing,
by putting together a great number of experiments, the probability is as ten to one, that, take
436
one time with another, one in ten of the stones which have these marks (and no visible signs
to the contrary) proves to be not a true diamond. Then it will follow, that when I find a
particular stone with these marks, and nothing to the contrary, there is a probability of ten
to one, concerning that stone, that it is a diamond; and so concerning each stone that I find
with these marks: but if we take ten of these together, it is as probable as not, that some one
of the ten is spurious; because, if it were not as likely as not, that one to ten is false, or if
taking one ten with another, there were not one in ten that was false, then the probability of
those, that have these marks, being true diamonds, would be more than ten to one, contrary
to the supposition; because that is what we mean by a probability of ten to one, that they are
not false, viz. that take one ten with another there will be one false stone among them, and
no more. Hence if we take a hundred such stones together, the probability will be just ten
1751
PART I. The Question stated and explained.