will be time when he will cease to exist; but into the Eternal world these ideas of time do
not enter; to a sober thinker they have nothing akin to that world. He who considers what
the divine life really is will get beyond the ‘sometime,’ the ‘before,’ and the ‘after,’ and every
mark whatever of this extension in time; he will have lofty views upon a subject so lofty; nor
will he deem that the Absolute is bound by those laws which he observes to be in force in
human generation.
Passion precedes the concrete existence of man; certain material foundations are laid
for the formation of the living creature; beneath it all is Nature, by God’s will, with her
wonder-working, putting everything under contribution for the proper proportion of nutri-
tion for that which is to be born, taking from each terrestrial element the amount necessary
for the particular case, receiving the co-operation of a measured time, and as much of the
food of the parents as is necessary for the formation of the child: in a word Nature, advancing
through all these processes by which a human life is built up, brings the non-existent to the
birth; and accordingly we say that, non-existent once, it now is born; because, at one time
not being, at another it begins to be. But when it comes to the Divine generation the mind
rejects this ministration of Nature, and this fulness of time in contributing to the develop-
ment, and everything else which our argument contemplated as taking place in human
generation; and he who enters on divine topics with no carnal conceptions will not fall down
again to the level of any of those debasing thoughts, but seeks for one in keeping with the
majesty of the thing to be expressed; he will not think of passion in connexion with that
which is passionless, or count the Creator of all Nature as in need of Nature’s help, or admit
extension in time into the Eternal life; he will see that the Divine generation is to be cleared
of all such ideas, and will allow to the title ‘Father’ only the meaning that the Only-begotten
94
is not Himself without a source, but derives from That the cause of His being; though, as
for the actual beginning of His subsistence, he will not calculate that, because he will not be
able to see any sign of the thing in question. ‘Older’ and ‘younger’ and all such notions are
found to involve intervals of time; and so, when you mentally abstract time in general, all
such indications are got rid of along with it.
Since, then, He who is with the Father, in some inconceivable category, before the ages
admits not of a ‘sometime,’ He exists by generation indeed, but nevertheless He never begins
to exist. His life is neither in time, nor in place. But when we take away these and all suchlike
ideas in contemplating the subsistence of the Son, there is only one thing that we can even
think of as before Him—i.e. the Father. But the Only-begotten, as He Himself has told us,
is in the Father, and so, from His nature, is not open to the supposition that He ever existed
not. If indeed the Father ever was not, the eternity of the Son must be cancelled retrospectively
in consequence of this nothingness of the Father: but if the Father is always, how can the
Son ever be non-existent, when He cannot be thought of at all by Himself apart from the
Father, but is always implied silently in the name Father. This name in fact conveys the two
178
Answer to the question he is always asking, “Can He who is be begotten?