Chapter
X.—One Has Succeeded in Finding Definite Truth, When He Believes.
Heretical Wits are Always Offering Many Things for Vain Discussion, But
We are Not to Be Always Seeking.
Now the reason of this saying is comprised in
three points: in the matter, in the time, in the limit.
1969
In the matter, so that you must consider
what it is
you have to seek; in the time,
when
you have
to seek; in the limit,
how long
. What you have “to
seek,” then, is that which Christ has taught,
1970
(and you must go on seeking) of course for
such time as you fail to find,
1971
—until indeed
you find
1972
it. But you have
succeeded in finding
1973
when you have
believed. For you would not have believed if you had not found; as
neither would you have sought except with a view to find. Your object,
therefore, in seeking
was
to find; and your object in finding
was
to believe. All further delay for seeking and finding you
have prevented
1974
by believing. The
very fruit of your seeking has determined for you this limit.
This boundary
1975
has He set for you
Himself, who is unwilling that you should believe anything else than
what He has taught, or, therefore, even seek for it. If, however,
because so many other things have been taught by one and another, we
are on that account bound to go on seeking, so long as we are able to
find anything, we must (at that rate) be ever seeking, and never
believe anything at all. For where shall be the end of seeking? where
the stop
1976
in believing? where
the completion in finding? (Shall it be) with Marcion? But even
Valentinus proposes (to us the) maxim, “Seek, and ye shall
find.” (Then shall it be) with Valentinus? Well, but Apelles,
too, will assail me with the same quotation; Hebion also, and Simon,
and all in turn, have no other argument wherewithal to entice me, and
draw me over to their side. Thus I shall be nowhere, and still be
encountering
1977
(that challenge),
“Seek, and ye shall find,” precisely as if I had no
resting-place;
1978
as if (indeed) I
had never found that which Christ has taught—that which
ought
1979
to be sought, that which must needs
1980
be believed.
1969
In modo.
1970
This is,
“
the matter
.”
1971
“The
time.”
1972
“The
limit.”
1973
Invenisti.
1974
Fixisti,
“determined.”
1975
Fossam.
1976
Statio,
“resting-place.”
1977
Dum convenero.
1978
This is the rendering
of Oehler’s text, “et velut si nusquam. There are
other readings of this obscure passage, of which as we add the two most
intelligible. The
Codex Agobardinus
has, “et velim
si nunquam;” that is, “and I would that I were
nowhere,” with no fixed belief—in such wise as never to
have had the truth; not, as must now be, to have forfeited it.
(Dodgson). This seems far-fetched, and inferior to the reading of
Pamelius and his
mss.
: “et
velint me sic esse nusquam;”—or (as Semler puts it)
“velint sic nusquam;” i.e., “and they (the heretics)
would wish me to be nowhere”—without the fixed faith of the
Catholic. This makes good sense. [Semler is here mentioned, and if
anybody wishes to understand what sort of editor he was, he may be
greatly amused by Kaye’s examination of some of his positions,
pp. 64–84. Elucidation II.]
1979
Oportet.
1980
Necesse est. Observe
these degrees of obligation.