64 oosram ACCORDING ro caar. n.
Sup. 2.
Aug. do
Civ. Dei,
v. 1.
Aug. de
Civ. Dei,
troductionof the account of the starwould leadus rather
to callthispart of the history,‘The Nativity,’than ‘The
Gospel.’ GREooRY. But far be it from the hearts of the
faithfulto callany thing,‘fate.’AUG. For by the word
‘fate,’in common acceptation,is meant the dispositionof
the starsat the moment of a person’sbirth or conception;
to which some assign a power independent of the willof
God. These must be kept at a distancefrom the earsof all
who desireto be worshippers of Gods of any sort. But
othersthink the starshave thisvirtuecommitted to them by
the greatGod; wherein they greatlywrong the skies,in that
they impute to theirsplendenthost the decreeingof crimes,
such as should any earthlypeople decree,theircityshould
in the judgment of mankind deserveto be utterlydestroyed.
PsnUno-CnRvs. If then any should become an adultereror
homicide through means of the planets,how great is the
evil and wickedness of those stars, or rather of Him who
made them? For as God knows things to come, and what
evilsare to springfrom thosestars;if He would not hinder
it,He is not good; ifHe would but could not,He isweak.
Again, ifitbe of the starthatwe are eithergood or bad, we
have neither merit nor demerit, as being involuntary agents ;
and why should I be punished for sin which I have done
not wilfully,but by necessity? The very commands of God
againstsin,and exhortationstorighteousness,overthrow such
folly. For where a man has not power to do, or where he
has not power to forbear,who would command him either
to do or to forbear? GmtooRY NYss. How vain moreover
is prayer for those who live by fate; Divine Providence
is banished from the world together with piety,and man
is made the mere instrument of the siderealmotions. For
thesethey say move to action,not only the bodilymembers,
but the thoughts of the mind. In a word, they who teach
this,take away allthat is in us, and the very nature of
a contingency; which is nothing lessthan to overturn all
things. For where willthere be freewill? but that which
is in us must be free. AUG. It cannot be saidto be utterly
absurd to supposethat siderealafliatusshould influence the
stateof the body, when we see that it is by the approach
and departure of the sun that the seasonsof the year are