351
Excursus on the Condemnation of Pope Honorius.
To this decree attaches not only the necessary importance and interest which belongs
to any ecumenical decision upon a disputed doctrinal question with regard to the incarnation
of the Son of God, but an altogether accidental interest, arising from the fact that by this
decree a Pope of Rome is stricken with anathema in the person of Honorius. I need hardly
remind the reader how many interesting and difficult questions in theology such an action
on the part of an Ecumenical Council raises, and how all important, not to say vital, to such
as accept the ruling of the recent Vatican Council, it is that some explanation of this fact
should be arrived at which will be satisfactory. It would be highly improper for me in these
pages to discuss the matter theologically. Volumes on each side have been written on this
subject, and to these I must refer the reader, but in doing so I hope I may be pardoned if I
add a word of counsel—to read both sides. If one’s knowledge is derived only from modern
Eastern, Anglican or Protestant writers, such as “Janus and the Council,” the Père Gratry’s
“Letters,” or Littledale’s controversial books against Rome, one is apt to be as much one-
sided as if he took his information from Cardinal Baronius, Cardinal Bellarmine,
Rohrbacher’s History, or from the recent work on the subject by Pennacchi.335 Perhaps the
average reader will hardly find a more satisfactory treatment than that by Bossuet in the
Defensio. (Liber VII., cap. xxi., etc.)
It will be sufficient for the purposes of this volume to state that Roman Catholic Curialist
writers are not at one as to how the matter is to be treated. Pennacchi, in his work referred
to above, is of opinion that Honorius’s letters were strictly speaking Papal decrees, set forth
auctoritate apostolica, and therefore irreformable, but he declares, contrary to the opinion
of almost all theologians and to the decree of this Council, that they are orthodox, and that
the Council erred in condemning them; as he expresses it, the decree rests upon an error in
facto dogmatico. To save an Ecumenical Synod from error, he thinks the synod ceased to
be ecumenical before it took this action, and was at that time only a synod of a number of
Orientals! Cardinal Baronius has another way out of the difficulty. He says that the name
of Honorius was forged and put in the decree by an erasure in the place of the name of
Theodore, the quondam Patriarch, who soon after the Council got himself restored to the
Patriarchal position. Baronius moreover holds that Honorius’s letters have been corrupted,
that the Acts of the Council have been corrupted, and, in short, that everything which declares
or proves that Honorius was a heretic or was condemned by an Ecumenical Council as such,
is untrustworthy and false. The groundlessness, not to say absurdity, of Baronius’s view
has been often exposed by those of his own communion, a brief but sufficient summary of
the refutation will be found in Hefele, who while taking a very halting and unsatisfactory
position himself, yet is perfectly clear that Baronius’s contention is utterly indefensible.336
335 Pennacchi. De Honorii I., Romani Pontificis, causa in Concilio VI.
336 Hefele. History of the Councils. Vol. V., p. 190 et seqq.
Excursus on the Condemnation of Pope Honorius.
623
Excursus on the Condemnation of Pope Honorius.