be free from the charge of temerity will dare to say how many his offspring numbered? It
was possible enough that Adam was divinely prompted to say, after Seth was born, “For
God hath raised up to me another seed for Abel,” because that son was to be capable of
representing Abel’s holiness, not because he was born first after him in point of time. Then
because it is written, “And Seth lived 205 years,” or, according to the Hebrew reading, “105
years, and begat Enos,”815 who but a rash man could affirm that this was his first-born?
Will any man do so to excite our wonder, and cause us to inquire how for so many years he
remained free from sexual intercourse, though without any purpose of continuing so, or
how, if he did not abstain, he yet had no children? Will any man do so when it is written
of him, “And he begat sons and daughters, and all the days of Seth were 912 years, and he
died?”816 And similarly regarding those whose years are afterwards mentioned, it is not
disguised that they begat sons and daughters.
Consequently it does not at all appear whether he who is named as the son was himself
the first begotten. Nay, since it is incredible that those fathers were either so long in attaining
puberty, or could not get wives, or could not impregnate them, it is also incredible that those
sons were their first-born. But as the writer of the sacred history designed to descend by
well-marked intervals through a series of generations to the birth and life of Noah, in whose
time the flood occurred, he mentioned not those sons who were first begotten, but those by
whom the succession was handed down.
Let me make this clearer by here inserting an example, in regard to which no one can
have any doubt that what I am asserting is true. The evangelist Matthew, where he designs
297
to commit to our memories the generation of the Lord’s flesh by a series of parents, beginning
from Abraham and intending to reach David, says, “Abraham begat Isaac;”817 why did he
not say Ishmael, whom he first begat? Then “Isaac begat Jacob;” why did he not say Esau,
who was the first-born? Simply because these sons would not have helped him to reach
David. Then follows, “And Jacob begat Judah and his brethren:” was Judah the first begotten?
“Judah,” he says, “begat Pharez and Zara;” yet neither were these twins the first-born of
Judah, but before them he had begotten three other sons. And so in the order of the gener-
ations he retained those by whom he might reach David, so as to proceed onwards to the
end he had in view. And from this we may understand that the antediluvians who are
mentioned were not the first-born, but those through whom the order of the succeeding
generations might be carried on to the patriarch Noah. We need not, therefore, weary
ourselves with discussing the needless and obscure question as to their lateness of reaching
puberty.
815 Gen. v. 6.
816 Gen. v. 8.
817 Matt. i.
672
Whether It is Credible that the Men of the Primitive Age Abstained from…