171
Introduction on the Number of the Canons.
(Hefele, History of the Councils, Vol. II., p. 351.)
The number of canons drawn up by this synod is doubtful. The old Greek codices and
the Greek commentators of the Middle Ages, Zonaras and Balsamon, enumerate seven; the
old Latin translations—viz. the Prisca, those by Dionysius Exiguus and Isidore, as well as
the Codex of Luna—only recognize the first four canons of the Greek text, and the fact that
they agree in this point is the more important as they are wholly independent of each other,
and divide and arrange those canons of Constantinople which they do acknowledge quite
differently.
Because, however, in the Prisca the canons of Constantinople are only placed after those
of the fourth General Council, the Ballerini brothers conclude that they were not contained
at all in the oldest Greek collections of canons, and were inserted after the Council of
Chalcedon. But it was at this very Council of Chalcedon that the first three canons of
Constantinople were read out word for word. As however, they were not separately
numbered, but were there read under the general title of Synodicon Synodi Secundæ, Fuchs
concluded they were not originally in the form in which we now possess them, but, without
being divided into numbers, formed a larger and unbroken decree, the contents of which
were divided by later copyists and translators into several different canons. And hence the
very different divisions of these canons in the Prisca, Dionysius, and Isidore may be ex-
plained. The fact, however, that the old Latin translations all agree in only giving the first
four canons of the Greek text, seems to show that the oldest Greek manuscripts, from which
those translations were made, did not contain the fifth, sixth, and seventh, and that these
last did not properly belong to this Synod, but were later additions. To this must be added
that the old Greek Church-historians, in speaking of the affairs of the second General
Council, only mention those points which are contained in the first four canons, and say
nothing of what, according to the fifth, sixth, and seventh canons, had also been decided at
Constantinople. At the very least, the seventh canon cannot have emanated from this
Council, since in the sixth century John Scholasticus did not receive it into his collection,
although he adopted the fifth and sixth. It is also missing in many other collections; and in
treating specially of this canon further on, we shall endeavour to show the time and manner
of its origin. But the fifth and sixth canons probably belong to the Synod of Constantinople
of the following year, as Beveridge, the Ballerini, and others conjectured. The Greek scholi-
asts, Zonaras and Balsamon, and later on Tillemont, Beveridge, Van Espen and Herbst, have
given more or less detailed commentaries on all these canons.
Introduction on the Number of the Canons.
340
Introduction on the Number of the Canons.