xii INTRODUCTION.
ing him, and danger on every side, to come forward and
attempt calmly to show the heathen that there was no reason
for their complaints against the Christians. In the later
books there is a change in tone, upon which we cannot
now dwell, although it is marked. In one passage he asks
indignantly, * Why should our writings be given to the
flames, our meetings be cruelly broken up, in which prayer is
offered to the supreme God, peace and pardon are asked for
all in authority, for soldiers, kings, friends, enemies?" In
the calm tranquillity of the last half of the third century
these words could hardly have been written, but they are a
striking testimony to the terms of the imperial edict issued
in the year 303 A.D. So, too, the expression of anger and
disgust at the anti-pagan character of some of Cicero's
works, noticed in iii. 7, belongs to the incipient stages of
persecution.
Nor must it be supposed that the whole work may be
referred to the era which ensued after the abdication of
Diocletian, in 305. From this time an apology for Chris-
tianity with such a design would have been an anachronism,
for it was no longer necessary to disarm the fears of the
heathen by showing that the gods could not be enraged at
the Christians. It has further to be noticed, that although
it is perfectly clear that Arnobius spent much time on his
apology, it has never been thoroughly revised, and does not
seem to have been ever finished.”
We surely have in all this sufficient reason to assign the
composition of these books adversus Gentes to the end of the
third and beginning of the fourth centuries. Beyond this we
cannot go, for we have no data from which to derive further
inferences.
$9. We have seen that the facts transmitted to us are
very few and scanty indeed; but, few as they are, they sug-
gest an interesting picture. Arnobius comes before us in
_Sicca; we are made spectators of two scenes of his life there,
and the rest—the beginning and the end—are shrouded in
liy. 36, p. 218. - ? Cf. pp. 347, n. 3, and 364, n. 3.