258 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Book v.
religious awe’ and fear on any account, to wrap those
mysteries in dark obscurity, what audacity it shows in you
to wish to understand what they did not wish, to know your-
selves and make all acquainted with that which they vainly
attempted to conceal by words which did not suggest the truth!
94. But, agreeing with you that in all these stories stags
are TEES of instead of Iphigenias, yet, how are you sure,
when you either explain or unfold these allegories, that you
give the same explanations or have the same ideas which
were entertained by the writers themselves in the silence of
their thoughts, but expressed by words not adapted? to what
was meant, but to something else? You say that the falling
of rain into the bosom of the earth was spoken of as the
union of Jupiter and Ceres; another may both devise with
greater subtlety, and conjecture with some probability, some-
thing else ; a third, a fourth may [do the same]; and as the
characteristics of the minds of the thinkers show themselves,
so each thing may be explained in an infinite number of
ways. For since all that allegory, as it is called, is taken
from narratives expressly made obscure,’ and has no certain
limit within which the meaning of the story,* as it is called,
should be firmly fixed and unchangeable, it is open to every
one to put the meaning into it which he pleases, and to assert
that that has been adopted? to which his thoughts and
surmises? led him. But this being the case, how can you
obtain certainty from what is doubtful, and attach one sense
only to an expression which you see to be explained in in-
numerable different ways ?*
35. Finally, if you think it right, returning to our inquiry,
we ask this of you, whether you think that all stories about
the gods? that is, without any exception,’ have been written
1 Lit., ‘‘ fear of any reason and of religion." ? Lit., ** proper.”
3 Lit., ** from shut up things." * Rei. 5 Lit., “ placed.”
6 Lit., ‘his suspicion and conjectural (perhaps ‘‘ probable") inference.”
7 Lit., **to be deduced with variety of expositions through numberless
ways.”
i The MS., first four edd., and Hild. read de Ais—'* about these,” cor-
rected in TA others dís or diis, as above.
9 Lit., ** each."