language, to argue that God, as it were, declaimed such words by Himself, when there was
no one in need of the information they would convey—such an idea, methinks, is at once
both blasphemous and absurd. Neither, then, did God speak in the Hebrew language, nor
did He express Himself according to any form in use among the Gentiles. But whatsoever
of God’s words are recorded by Moses or the Prophets, are indications of the Divine will,
flashing forth, now in one way, now in another, on the pure intellect of those holy men, ac-
cording to the measure of the grace of which they were partakers. Moses, then, spoke his
mother-tongue, and that in which he was educated. But he attributed these words to God,
277
as I have said, repeatedly, on account of the childishness of those who were being brought
to the knowledge of God, in order to give a clear representation of the Divine will, and to
render his hearers more obedient, as being awed by the authority of the speaker.
But this is denied by Eunomius, the author of all this contumely with which we are as-
sailed, and the companion and adviser of this impious band. For, changing insolence into
courtesy, I will present him with his own words. He maintains, in so many words, that he
has the testimony of Moses himself to his assertion that men were endowed with the use of
the things named, and of their names, by the Creator of nature, and that the naming of the
things given was prior in time to the creation of those who should use them. Now, if he is
in possession of some Moses of his own, from whom he has learned this wisdom, and,
making this his base of operations, relies on such statements as these, viz. that God, as he
himself says, lays down the laws of human speech, enacting that things shall be called in
one way and not in another, let him trifle as much as he pleases, with his Moses in the
background to support his assertions. But if there is only one Moses whose writings are the
common source of instruction to those who are learned in the Divine Word, we will freely
accept our condemnation if we find ourselves refuted by the law of that Moses. But where
did he find this law respecting verbs and nouns? Let him produce it in the very words of the
text. The account of the Creation, and the genealogy of the successive generations, and the
history of certain events, and the complex system of legislation, and various regulations in
regard to religious service and daily life, these are the chief heads of the writings of Moses.
But, if he says that there was any legislative enactment in regard to words, let him point it
out, and I will hold my tongue. But he cannot; for, if he could, he would not abandon the
more striking evidences of the Deity, for such as can only procure him ridicule, and not
credit, from men of sense. For to think it the essential point in piety to attribute the invention
of words to God, Whose praise the whole world and the wonders that are therein are incom-
petent to celebrate—must it not be a proceeding of extreme folly so to neglect higher grounds
of praise, and to magnify God on such as are purely human? His fiat preluded Creation, but
it was recorded by Moses after human fashion, though Divinely issued. That will of God,
then, which brought about the creation of the world by His Divine power, consisted, says
our careful student of the Scriptures, in the teaching of words. And as though God had said,
523
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.