§5.
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of
Eusebius
.
About the year 318, while
Alexander was bishop of Alexandria, the Arian controversy broke out in
that city, and the whole Eastern Church was soon involved in the
strife. We cannot enter here into a discussion of Arius’ views;
but in order to understand the rapidity with which the Arian party
grew, and the strong hold which it possessed from the very start in
Syria and Asia Minor, we must remember that Arius was not himself the
author of that system which we know as Arianism, but that he learned
the essentials of it from his instructor Lucian. The latter was one of
the most learned men of his age in the Oriental Church, and founded an
exegetico-theological school in Antioch, which for a number of years
stood outside of the communion of the orthodox Church in that city, but
shortly before the martyrdom of Lucian himself (which took place in 311
or 312) made its peace with the Church, and was recognized by it. He
was held in the highest reverence by his disciples, and exerted a great
influence over them even after his death. Among them were such men as
Arius, Eusebius of Nicomedia, Asterius, and others who were afterward
known as staunch Arianists. According to Harnack the chief points in
the system of Lucian and his disciples were the creation of the Son,
the denial of his co-eternity with the Father, and his immutability
acquired by persistent progress and steadfastness. His doctrine, which
differed
from that of Paul of Samosata chiefly in the fact that it was not
a man but a created heavenly being who became “Lord,” was
evidently the result of a combination of the teaching of Paul and of
Origen. It will be seen that we have here, at least in germ, all the
essential elements of Arianism proper: the creation of the Son out of
nothing, and consequently the conclusion that there was a time when he
was not; the distinction of his essence from that of the Father, but at
the same time the emphasis upon the fact that he “was not created
as the other creatures,” and is therefore to be sharply
distinguished from them. There was little for Arius to do but to
combine the elements given by Lucian in a more complete and
well-ordered system, and then to bring that system forward clearly and
publicly, and endeavor to make it the faith of the Church at large. His
christology was essentially opposed to the Alexandrian, and it was
natural that he should soon come into conflict with that church, of
which he was a presbyter (upon Lucian’s teaching and its relation
to Arianism, see Harnack’s
Dogmengeschichte
, II. p. 183
sq.).
Socrates (
H. E.
I. 5
sq.), Sozomen (
H. E.
I. 15) and Theodoret (
H. E.
I. 2
sq.), all of whom give accounts of the rise of Arianism, differ as to
the immediate occasion of the controversy, but agree that Arius was
excommunicated by a council convened at Alexandria, and that both he
and the bishop Alexander sent letters to other churches, the latter
defending his own course, the former complaining of his harsh
treatment, and endeavoring to secure adherents to his doctrine.
Eusebius of Nicomedia at once became his firm supporter, and was one of
the leading figures on the Arian side throughout the entire
controversy. His influential position as bishop of Nicomedia, the
imperial residence, and later of Constantinople, was of great advantage
to the Arian cause, especially toward the close of Constantine’s
reign. From a letter addressed by this Eusebius to Paulinus of Tyre
(Theodoret,
H. E.
I. 6) we learn that Eusebius of Cæsarea
was quite zealous in behalf of the Arian cause. The exact date of the
letter we do not know, but it must have been written at an early stage
of the controversy. Arius himself, in an epistle addressed to Eusebius
of Nicomedia (Theodoret,
H. E.
I. 5), claims Eusebius of
Cæsarea among others as accepting at least one of his fundamental
doctrines (“And since Eusebius, your brother in Cæsarea, and
Theodotus, and Paulinus, and Athanasius, and Gregory, and Ætius,
and all the bishops of the East say that God existed before the Son,
they have been condemned,” etc.). More than this, Sozomen (
H.
E.
I. 15) informs us that Eusebius of Cæsarea and two other
bishops, having been appealed to by Arius for “permission for
himself and his adherents, as he had already attained the rank of
presbyter, to form the people who were with them into a church,”
concurred with others “who were assembled in Palestine,” in
granting the petition of Arius, and permitting him to assemble the
people as before; but they “enjoined submission to Alexander, and
commanded Arius to strive incessantly to be restored to peace and
communion with him.” The addition of the last sentence is
noticeable, as showing that they did not care to support a presbyter in
open and persistent rebellion against his bishop. A fragment of a
letter written by our Eusebius to Alexander is still extant, and is
preserved in the proceedings of the Second Council of Nicæa, Act.
VI. Tom. V. (
Labbei et Cossartii Conc.
VII. col. 497). In this
epistle Eusebius strongly remonstrates with Alexander for having
misrepresented the views of Arius. Still further, in his epistle to
Alexander of Constantinople, Alexander of Alexandria (Theodoret,
H.
E.
I. 4) complains of three Syrian bishops “who side with
them [
i.e.
the Arians] and excite them to plunge deeper and
deeper into iniquity.” The reference here is commonly supposed to
be to Eusebius of Cæsarea, and his two friends Paulinus of Tyre
and Theodotus of Laodicea, who are known to have shown favor to Arius.
It is probable, though not certain, that our Eusebius is one of the
persons meant. Finally, many of the Fathers (above all Jerome and
Photius), and in addition to them the Second Council of Nicæa,
directly accuse Eusebius of holding the Arian heresy, as may be seen by
examining the testimonies quoted below on p. 67 sq. In agreement with
these early Fathers, many modern historians have attacked Eusebius with
great severity, and have endeavored to show that the opinion that he
was an Arian is supported by his own writings. Among those who have
judged him most harshly are Baronius (
ad ann.
340, c. 38 sq.),
Petavius
(
Dogm. Theol. de Trin
. I. c. 11 sq.), Scaliger (
In
Elencho Trihæresii
, c. 27, and
De emendatione temporum
,
Bk. VI. c. 1), Mosheim (
Ecclesiastical History
, Murdock’s
translation, I. p. 287 sq.), Montfaucon (
Prælim. in Comment. ad
Psalm
. c. VI.), and Tillemont (
H. E.
VII. p. 67 sq. 2d
ed.).
On the other hand, as may be
seen from the testimonies in Eusebius’ favor, quoted below on p.
57 sq., many of the Fathers, who were themselves orthodox, looked upon
Eusebius as likewise sound on the subject of the Trinity. He has been
defended in modern times against the charge of Arianism by a great many
prominent scholars; among others by Valesius in his
Life of
Eusebius
, by Bull (
Def. Fid. Nic
. II. 9. 20, III. 9. 3, 11),
Cave (
Lives of the Fathers
, II. p. 135 sq.), Fabricius (
Bibl.
Græc
. VI. p. 32 sq.), Dupin (
Bibl. Eccles
. II. p. 7
sq.), and most fully and carefully by Lee in his prolegomena to his
edition of Eusebius’
Theophania
, p. xxiv. sq. Lightfoot
also defends him against the charge of heresy, as do a great many other
writers whom it is not necessary to mention here. Confronted with such
diversity of opinion, both ancient and modern, what are we to conclude?
It is useless to endeavor, as Lee does, to clear Eusebius of all
sympathy with and leaning toward Arianism. It is impossible to explain
such widespread and continued condemnation of him by acknowledging only
that there are many expressions in his works which are in themselves
perfectly orthodox but capable of being wrested in such a way as to
produce a suspicion of possible Arianistic tendencies, for there are
such expressions in the works of multitudes of ancient writers whose
orthodoxy has never been questioned. Nor can the widespread belief that
he was an Arian be explained by admitting that he was for a time the
personal friend of Arius, but denying that he accepted, or in any way
sympathized with his views (cf. Newman’s
Arians
, p. 262).
There are in fact certain fragments of epistles extant, which are, to
say the least, decidedly Arianistic in their modes of expression, and
these must be reckoned with in forming an opinion of Eusebius’
views; for there is no reason to deny, as Lee does, that they are from
Eusebius’ own hand. On the other hand, to maintain, with some of
the Fathers and many of the moderns, that Eusebius was and continued
through life a genuine Arian, will not do in the face of the facts that
contemporary and later Fathers were divided as to his orthodoxy, that
he was honored highly by the Church of subsequent centuries, except at
certain periods, and was even canonized (see Lightfoot’s article,
p. 348), that he solemnly signed the Nicene Creed, which contained an
express condemnation of the distinctive doctrines of Arius, and finally
that at least in his later works he is thoroughly orthodox in his
expressions, and is explicit in his rejection of the two main theses of
the Arians,—that there
was a time when the Son of God was
not
, and that he was
produced out of nothing
. It is
impossible to enter here into a detailed discussion of such passages in
Eusebius’ works as bear upon the subject under dispute. Lee has
considered many of them at great length, and the reader may be referred
to him for further information.
A careful examination of them
will, I believe, serve to convince the candid student that there is a
distinction to be drawn between those works written before the rise of
Arius, those written between that time and the Council of Nicæa,
and those written after the latter. It has been very common to draw a
distinction between those works written before and those written after
the Council, but no one, so far as I know, has distinguished those
productions of Eusebius’ pen which appeared between 318 and 325,
and which were caused by the controversy itself, from all his other
writings. And yet such a distinction seems to furnish the key to the
problem. Eusebius’ opponents have drawn their strongest arguments
from the epistles which Eusebius wrote to Alexander and to Euphration;
his defenders have drawn their arguments chiefly from the works which
he produced subsequent to the year 325; while the exact bearing of the
expressions used in his works produced before the controversy broke out
has always been a matter of sharp dispute. Lee has abundantly shown his
Contra Marcel
., his
De Eccl. Theol
., his
Thephania
(which was written after the Council of Nicæa, and not, as Lee
supposes, before it), and other later works, to be thoroughly orthodox
and to contain nothing which a trinitarian might not have written. In
his
Hist. Eccl., Præparatio Evang., Demonstratio Evang
.,
and other earlier works,
although we find some
expressions employed which it would not have been possible for an
orthodox trinitarian to use after the Council of Nicæa, at least
without careful limitation to guard against misapprehension, there is
nothing even in these works which requires us to believe that he
accepted the doctrines of Arius’ predecessor, Lucian of Antioch;
that is, there is nothing distinctly and positively Arianistic about
them, although there are occasional expressions which might lead the
reader to expect that the writer would become an Arian if he ever
learned of Arius’ doctrines. But if there is seen to be a lack of
emphasis upon the divinity of the Son, or rather a lack of clearness in
the conception of the nature of that divinity, it must be remembered
that there was at this time no especial reason for emphasizing and
defining it, but there was on the contrary very good reason for laying
particular stress upon the subordination of the Son over against
Sabellianism, which was so widely prevalent during the third century,
and which was exerting an influence even over many orthodox theologians
who did not consciously accept Sabellianistic tenets. That Eusebius was
a decided subordinationist must be plain to every one that reads his
works with care, especially his earlier ones. It would be surprising if
he had not been, for he was born at a time when Sabellianism
(monarchianism) was felt to be the greatest danger to which orthodox
christology was exposed, and he was trained under the influence of the
followers of Origen, who had made it one of his chief aims to emphasize
the subordination of the Son over against that very monarchianism.
1
The same subordinationism may be clearly seen
in the writings of Dionysius of Alexandria and of Gregory Thaumaturgus,
two of Origen’s greatest disciples. It must not be forgotten that
at the beginning of the fourth century the problem of how to preserve
the Godhood of Christ and at the same time his subordination to the
Father (in opposition to the monarchianists) had not been solved.
Eusebius in his earlier writings shows that he holds both (he cannot be
convicted of denying Christ’s divinity), but that he is as far
from a solution of the problem, and is just as uncertain in regard to
the exact relation of Father and Son, as Tertullian, Hippolytus,
Origen, Dionysius, and Gregory Thaumaturgus were; is just as
inconsistent in his modes of expression as they, and yet no more so
(see Harnack’s
Dogmengeschichte
, I. pp. 628 sq. and 634
sq., for an exposition of the opinions of these other Fathers on the
subject). Eusebius, with the same immature and undeveloped views which
were held all through the third century, wrote those earlier works
which have given rise to so much dispute between those who accuse him
of Arianism and those who defend him against the charge. When he wrote
them he was neither Arian nor Athanasian, and for that reason passages
may be found in them which if written after the Council of Nicæa
might prove him an Arian, and other passages which might as truly prove
him an Athanasian, just as in the writings of Origen were found by both
parties passages to support their views, and in Gregory Thaumaturgus
passages apparently teaching Arianism, and others teaching its
opposite, Sabellianism (see Harnack,
ib
. p. 646).
Let us suppose now that
Eusebius, holding fast to the divinity of Christ, and yet convinced
just as firmly of his subordination to the Father, becomes acquainted
through Arius, or other like-minded disciples of Lucian of Antioch,
with a doctrine which seems to preserve the Godhood, while at the same
time emphasizing strongly the subordination of the Son, and which
formulates the relation of Father and Son in a clear and rational
manner. That he should accept such a doctrine eagerly is just what we
should expect, and just what we find him doing. In his epistles to
Alexander and Euphration, he shows himself an Arian, and Arius and his
followers were quite
right in claiming him as a supporter. There is that in the
epistles which is to be found nowhere in his previous writings, and
which distinctly separates him from the orthodox party. How then are we
to explain the fact that a few years later he signed the Nicene creed
and anathematized the doctrines of Arius? Before we can understand his
conduct, it is necessary to examine carefully the two epistles in
question. Such an examination will show us that what Eusebius is
defending in them is not genuine Arianism. He evidently thinks that it
is, evidently supposes that he and Arius are in complete agreement upon
the subjects under discussion; but he is mistaken. The extant fragments
of the two epistles are given below on p. 70. It will be seen that
Eusebius in them defends the Arian doctrine that there was a time when
the Son of God was not. It will be seen also that he finds fault with
Alexander for representing the Arians as teaching that the “Son
of God was made out of nothing, like all creatures,” and contends
that Arius teaches that the Son of God was
begotten
, and that he
was not produced like all creatures. We know that the Arians very
commonly applied the word “begotten” to Christ, using it in
such cases as synonymous with “created,” and thus not
implying, as the Athanasians did when they used the word, that he was
of one substance with the Father (compare, for instance, the
explanation of the meaning of the term given by Eusebius of Nicomedia
in his epistle to Paulinus; Theod.
H. E
. I. 6). It is evident
that the use of this word had deceived our Eusebius, and that he was
led by it to think that they taught that the Son was of the Father in a
peculiar sense, and did in reality partake in some way of essential
Godhood. And indeed it is not at all surprising that the words of
Arius, in his epistle to Alexander of Alexandria (see Athan.
Ep. de
conc. Arim. et Seleuc
., chap. II. §3; Oxford edition of
Athanasius’
Tracts against Arianism
, p. 97), quoted by
Eusebius in his epistle to the same Alexander, should give Eusebius
that impression. The words are as follows: “The God of the law,
and of the prophets, and of the New Testament before eternal ages begat
an only-begotten Son, through whom also He made the ages and the
universe. And He begat him not in appearance, but in truth, and
subjected him to his own will, unchangeable and immutable, a perfect
creature of God, but not as one of the creatures.” Arius’
use here of the word “begat,” and his qualification of the
word “creature” by the adjective “perfect,” and
by the statement that he was “not as one of the creatures”
naturally tended to make Eusebius think that Arius acknowledged a real
divinity of the Son, and that appeared to him to be all that was
necessary. Meanwhile Alexander in his epistle to Alexander of
Constantinople (Theod.
H. E
. I. 4) had, as Eusebius says,
misstated Arius’ opinion, or at least had attributed to him the
belief that Christ was “made like all other men that have ever
been born,” whereas Arius expressly disclaims such a belief.
Alexander undoubtedly thought that that was the legitimate result to
which the other views of Arius must lead; but Eusebius did not think
so, and felt himself called upon to remonstrate with Alexander for what
seemed to him the latter’s unfairness in the matter.
When we examine the
Cæsarean creed
2
which Eusebius presented
to the Council as a fair statement of his belief, we find nothing in it
inconsistent with the acceptance of the kind of Arianism which he
defends in his epistle to Alexander, and which he evidently supposed to
be practically the Arianism of Arius himself. In his epistle to
Euphration, however, Eusebius seems at first glance to go further and
to give up the real divinity of the Son. His words are, “Since
the Son is himself God, but not true God.” But we have no right
to interpret these words, torn as they are from the context which might
make their meaning perfectly plain, without due regard to
Eusebius’ belief expressed elsewhere in this epistle, and in his
epistle to Alexander which was evidently written about the same time.
In the epistle to Alexander he clearly reveals a belief in the real
divinity of the Son, while in the other fragment of his epistle to
Euphration he dwells upon the subordination of the Son and approves the
Arian opinion, which he had defended also in the other epistle, that
the “Father was before the Son.” The expression, “not
true God” (a very common Arian expression; see Athan.
Orat. c.
Arian
. I. 6) seems therefore to have been
used by Eusebius to express a
belief, not that the Son did not possess real divinity (as the genuine
Arians used it), but that he was not equal to the Father, who, to
Eusebius’ thought, was “true God.” He indeed
expressly calls the Son
θεός
, which
shows—when the sense in which he elsewhere uses the word is
considered—that he certainly did believe him to partake of
Godhood, though, in some mysterious way, in a smaller degree, or in a
less complete manner than the Father. That Eusebius misunderstood
Arius, and did not perceive that he actually denied all real deity to
the Son, was due doubtless in part to his lack of theological insight
(Eusebius was never a great theologian), in part to his habitual dread
of Sabellianism (of which Arius had accused Alexander, and toward which
Eusebius evidently thought that the latter was tending), which led him
to look with great favor upon the pronounced subordinationism of Arius,
and thus to overlook the dangerous extreme to which Arius carried that
subordinationism.
We are now, the writer hopes,
prepared to admit that Eusebius, after the breaking out of the Arian
controversy, became an Arian, as he understood Arianism, and supported
that party with considerable vigor; and that not as a result of mere
personal friendship, but of theological conviction. At the same time,
he was then, as always, a peace-loving man, and while lending Arius his
approval and support, he united with other Palestinian bishops in
enjoining upon him submission to his bishop (Sozomen,
H. E
. I.
15). As an Arian, then, and yet possessed with the desire of securing,
if it were possible, peace and harmony between the two factions,
Eusebius appeared at the Council of Nicæa, and there signed a
creed containing Athanasian doctrine and anathematizing the chief
tenets of Arius. How are we to explain his conduct? We shall, perhaps,
do best to let him explain his own conduct. In his letter to the church
of Cæsarea (preserved by Socrates,
H. E
. I. 8, as well as
by other authors), he writes as follows:—
“What was transacted
concerning ecclesiastical faith at the Great Council assembled at
Nicæa you have probably learned, Beloved, from other sources,
rumour being wont to precede the accurate account of what is doing. But
lest in such reports the circumstances of the case have been
misrepresented, we have been obliged to transmit to you, first, the
formula of faith presented by ourselves; and next, the second, which
the Fathers put forth with some additions to our words. Our own paper,
then, which was read in the presence of our most pious Emperor, and
declared to be good and unexceptionable, ran thus:—
“‘As we have
received from the Bishops who preceded us, and in our first
catechisings, and when we received the Holy Laver, and as we have
learned from the divine Scriptures, and as we believed and taught in
the presbytery, and in the Episcopate itself, so believing also at the
time present, we report to you our faith, and it is
this:—
“‘We believe in One
God, the Father Almighty, the Maker of all things visible and
invisible. And in One Lord Jesus Christ, the Word of God, God from God,
Light from Light, Life from Life, Son Only-begotten, first-born of
every creature, before all the ages, begotten from the Father, by whom
also all things were made; who for our salvation was made flesh, and
lived among men, and suffered, and rose again the third day, and
ascended to the Father, and will come again in glory to judge quick and
dead. And we believe also in One Holy Ghost; believing each of These to
be and to exist, the Father truly Father, and the Son truly Son, and
the Holy Ghost truly Holy Ghost, as also our Lord, sending forth His
disciples for the preaching, said,
Go, teach all nations, baptizing
them in the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy
Ghost
. Concerning whom we confidently affirm that so we hold, and
so we think, and so we have held aforetime, and we maintain this faith
unto the death, anathematizing every godless heresy. That this we have
ever thought from our heart and soul, from the time we recollect
ourselves, and now think and say in truth, before God Almighty and our
Lord Jesus Christ do we witness, being able by proofs to show and to
convince you, that, even in times past, such has been our belief and
preaching.’
“On this faith being
publicly put forth by us, no room for contradiction appeared; but our
most pious Emperor, before any one else, testified that it comprised
most orthodox statements. He confessed, moreover, that such were his
own sentiments; and he advised all present to agree to it, and to
subscribe its articles and to assent to them, with the insertion of the
single word, ‘One in substance’ (
ὁμοούσιος
), which, moreover, he interpreted as not in the sense of
the affections of bodies, nor as if the Son subsisted from the Father,
in the way of division, or any sever
ance; for that the immaterial
and intellectual and incorporeal nature could not be the subject of any
corporeal affection, but that it became us to conceive of such things
in a divine and ineffable manner. And such were the theological remarks
of our most wise and most religious Emperor; but they, with a view to
the addition of ‘One in substance,’ drew up the following
formula:—
“‘We believe in One
God, the Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and
invisible:— And in One Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God,
begotten of the Father, Only-begotten, that is, from the Substance of
the Father; God from God, Light from Light, very God from very God,
begotten, not made, One in substance with the Father, by whom all
things were made, both things in heaven and things in earth; who for us
men and for our salvation came down and was made flesh, was made man,
suffered, and rose again the third day, ascended into heaven, and
cometh to judge quick and dead.
“‘And in the Holy
Ghost. But those who say, “Once He was not,” and
“Before His generation He was not,” and “He came to
be from nothing,” or those who pretend that the Son of God is
“Of other subsistence or substance,” or
“created,” or “alterable,” or
“mutable,” the Catholic Church
anathematizes.’
“On their dictating this
formula, we did not let it pass without inquiry in what sense they
introduced ‘of the substance of the Father,’ and ‘one
in substance with the Father.’ Accordingly questions and
explanations took place, and the meaning of the words underwent the
scrutiny of reason. And they professed that the phrase ‘of the
substance’ was indicative of the Son’s being indeed from
the Father, yet without being as if a part of Him. And with this
understanding we thought good to assent to the sense of such religious
doctrine, teaching, as it did, that the Son was from the Father, not,
however, a part of His substance. On this account we assented to the
sense ourselves, without declining even the term ‘One in
substance,’ peace being the object which we set before us, and
steadfastness in the orthodox view. In the same way we also admitted
‘begotten, not made’; since the Council alleged that
‘made’ was an appellative common to the other creatures
which came to be through the Son, to whom the Son had no likeness.
Wherefore, said they, He was not a work resembling the things which
through Him came to be, but was of a substance which is too high for
the level of any work, and which the Divine oracles teach to have been
generated from the Father, the mode of generation being inscrutable and
incalculable to every generated nature. And so, too, on examination
there are grounds for saying that the Son is ‘one in
substance’ with the Father; not in the way of bodies, nor like
mortal beings, for He is not such by division of substance, or by
severance; no, nor by any affection, or alteration, or changing of the
Father’s substance and power (since from all such the ingenerate
nature of the Father is alien), but because ‘one in substance
with the Father’ suggests that the Son of God bears no
resemblance to the generated creatures, but that to His Father alone
who begat Him is He in every way assimilated, and that He is not of any
other subsistence and substance, but from the Father.
“To which term also, thus
interpreted, it appeared well to assent; since we were aware that, even
among the ancients, some learned and illustrious Bishops and writers
have used the term ‘one in substance’ in their theological
teaching concerning the Father and Son. So much, then, be said
concerning the faith which was published; to which all of us assented,
not without inquiry, but according to the specified senses, mentioned
before the most religious Emperor himself, and justified by the
fore-mentioned considerations. And as to the anathematism published by
them at the end of the Faith, it did not pain us, because it forbade to
use words not in Scripture, from which almost all the confusion and
disorder of the Church have come. Since, then, no divinely inspired
Scripture has used the phrases, ‘out of nothing’ and
‘once He was not,’ and the rest which follow, there
appeared no ground for using or teaching them; to which also we
assented as a good decision, since it had not been our custom hitherto
to use these terms. Moreover, to anathematize ‘Before His
generation He was not’ did not seem preposterous, in that it is
confessed by all that the Son of God was before the generation
according to the flesh. Nay, our most religious Emperor did at the time
prove, in a speech, that He was in being even according to His divine
generation which is before all ages, since even before he was
generated
in energy, He was in virtue with the Father ingenerately, the
Father being always Father, as King always and Saviour always, having
all things in virtue, and being always in the same respects and in the
same way. This we have been forced to transmit to you, Beloved, as
making clear to you the deliberation of our inquiry and assent, and how
reasonably we resisted even to the last minute, as long as we were
offended at statements which differed from our own, but received
without contention what no longer pained us, as soon as, on a candid
examination of the sense of the words, they appeared to us to coincide
with what we ourselves have professed in the faith which we have
already published.”
3
It will be seen that while the
expressions “of the substance of the Father,”
“begotten not made,” and “One in substance,” or
“consubstantial with the Father,” are all explicitly
anti-Arianistic, yet none of them contradicts the doctrines held by
Eusebius before the Council, so far as we can learn them from his
epistles to Alexander and Euphration and from the Cæsarean creed.
His own explanation of those expressions, which it is to be observed
was the explanation given by the Council itself, and which therefore he
was fully warranted in accepting,—even though it may not have
been so rigid as to satisfy an Athanasius,—shows us how this is.
He had believed before that the Son partook of the Godhood in very
truth, that He was “begotten,” and therefore “not
made,” if “made” implied something different from
“begotten,” as the Nicene Fathers held that it did; and he
had believed before that the “Son of God has no resemblance to
created’ things, but is in every respect like the Father only who
begat him, and that He is of no other substance or essence than the
Father,” and therefore if that was what the word
“Consubstantial” (
ὁμοούσιος
) meant he could not do otherwise than accept that
too.
It is clear that the dread of
Sabellianism was still before the eyes of Eusebius, and was the cause
of his hesitation in assenting to the various changes, especially to
the use of the word
ὁμοούσιος
, which had been a Sabellian word and had been rejected on
that account by the Synod of Antioch, at which Paul of Samosata had
been condemned some sixty years before.
It still remains to explain
Eusebius’ sanction of the anathemas attached to the creed which
expressly condemn at least one of the beliefs which he had himself
formerly held, viz.: that the “Father was before the Son,”
or as he puts it elsewhere, that “He who is begat him who was
not.” The knot might of course be simply cut by supposing an act
of hypocrisy on his part, but the writer is convinced that such a
conclusion does violence to all that we know of Eusebius and of his
subsequent treatment of the questions involved in this discussion. It
is quite possible to suppose that a real change of opinion on his part
took place during the sessions of the Council. Indeed when we realize
how imperfect and incorrect a conception of Arianism he had before the
Council began, and how clearly its true bearing was there brought out
by its enemies, we can see that he could not do otherwise than change;
that he must have become either an out-and-out Arian, or an opponent of
Arianism as he did. When he learned, and learned for the first time,
that Arianism meant the denial of all essential divinity to Christ, and
when he saw that it involved the ascription of mutability and of other
finite attributes to him, he must either change entirely his views on
those points or he must leave the Arian party. To him who with all his
subordinationism had laid in all his writings so much stress on the
divinity of the Word (even though he had not realized exactly what that
divinity involved) it would have been a revolution in his Christian
life and faith to have admitted what he now learned that Arianism
involved. Sabellianism had been his dread, but now this new fear, which
had aroused so large a portion of the Church, seized him too, and he
felt that stand must be made against this too great separation of
Father and Son, which was leading to dangerous results. Under the
pressure of this fear it is not surprising that he should become
convinced that the Arian formula—“there was a time when the
Son was not”—involved serious consequences, and that
Alexander and his followers should have succeeded in pointing out to
him its untruth, because it led necessarily to a false conclusion. It
is not surprising, moreover, that they should have succeeded in
explaining to him at least
partially their belief, which,
as his epistle to Alexander shows, had before been absolutely
incomprehensible, that the Son was generated from all eternity, and
that therefore the Father did not exist before him in a temporal
sense.
He says toward the close of his
epistle to the Cæsarean church that he had not been accustomed to
use such expressions as “There was a time when he was not,”
“He came to be from nothing,” etc. And there is no reason
to doubt that he speaks the truth. Even in his epistles to Alexander
and Euphration he does not use those phrases (though he does defend the
doctrine taught by the first of them), nor does Arius himself, in the
epistle to Alexander upon which Eusebius apparently based his knowledge
of the system, use those expressions, although he too teaches the same
doctrine. The fact is that in that epistle Arius studiously avoids such
favorite Arian phrases as might emphasize the differences between
himself and Alexander, and Eusebius seems to have avoided them for the
same reason. We conclude then that Eusebius was not an Arian (nor an
adherent of Lucian) before 318, that soon after that date he became an
Arian in the sense in which he understood Arianism, but that during the
Council of Nicæa he ceased to be one in any sense. His writings in
later years confirm the course of doctrinal development which we have
supposed went on in his mind. He never again defends Arian doctrines in
his works, and yet he never becomes an Athanasian in his emphasis upon
the
ὁμοούσιον
. In fact he represents a mild orthodoxy, which is always
orthodox—when measured by the Nicene creed as interpreted by the
Nicene Council—and yet is always mild. Moreover, he never
acquired an affection for the word
ὁμοούσιος
, which to his mind was bound up with too many evil
associations ever to have a pleasant sound to him. He therefore
studiously avoided it in his own writings, although clearly showing
that he believed fully in what the Nicene Council had explained it to
mean. It must be remembered that during many years of his later life he
was engaged in controversy with Marcellus, a thorough-going Sabellian,
who had been at the time of the Council one of the strongest of
Athanasius’ colleagues. In his contest with him it was again
anti-Sabellianistic polemics which absorbed him and increased his
distaste for
ὁμοούσιον
and minimized his emphasis upon the distinctively
anti-Arianistic doctrines formulated at Nicæa. For any except the
very wisest minds it was a matter of enormous difficulty to steer
between the two extremes in those times of strife; and while combating
Sabellianism not to fall into Arianism, and while combating the latter
not to be engulfed in the former. That Eusebius under the constant
pressure of the one fell into the other at one time, and was in
occasional danger of falling into it again in later years, can hardly
be cited as an evidence either of wrong heart or of weak head. An
Athanasius he was not, but neither was he an unsteady weather-cock, or
an hypocritical time-server.
1
It is
interesting to notice that the creed of the Cæsarean church which
Eusebius presented at the Council of Nice contains a clause which
certainly looks as if it had been composed in opposition to the
familiar formula of the Sabellians: “The same one is the Father,
the same one the Son, the same one the Holy Spirit” (τὸν αὐτὸν
εἶναι πατέρα,
τὸν αὐτὸν
εἶναι υἱ& 232·ν,
τὸν αὐτὸν
εἶναι ἅγιον
πνεῦμα; see
Epiphan.
Hær
. LXII. 1; and compare the statement made in
the same section, that the Sabellians taught that God acts in three
forms: in the form of the Father, as creator and lawgiver; in the form
of the Son, as redeemer; and in the form of the Spirit, as life-giver,
etc.). The clause of the Cæsarean creed referred to runs as
follows: “That the Father is truly Father, the Son truly Son, and
the Holy Spirit truly Holy Spirit” (πατέρα
ἀληθῶς
πατέρα, καὶ
υἱ& 232·ν
ἀληθῶς υἱ&
232·ν, καὶ
πνεῦμα ἅγιον
ἀληθῶς
ἅγιον). It is
significant that in the revised creed adopted by the Council these
words are omitted, evidently because the occasion for them no longer
existed, since not Sabellianism but Arianism was the heresy combated;
and because, more than that, the use of them would but weaken the
emphasis which the Council wished to put upon the essential divinity of
all three persons.
2
For a
translation of the creed see below, p. 16, where it is given as a part
of Eusebius’ epistle to the Church of Cæsarea.
3
The
translation is that of Newman, as given in the Oxford edition of
Athanasius’
Select Treatises against Arianism
, p. 59
sq.