decided the case at Rome were not good judges; there still remained a plenary Council of
the universal Church, in which these judges themselves might be put on their defence; so
that, if they were convicted of mistake, their decisions might be reversed.” Whether they
have done this or not, let them prove: for we easily prove that it was not done, by the fact
that the whole world does not communicate with them; or if it was done, they were defeated
there also, of which their state of separation from the Church is a proof.
20. What they actually did afterwards, however, is sufficiently shown in the letter of the
Emperor. For it was not before other bishops, but at the bar of the Emperor, that they dared
to bring the charge of wrong judgment against ecclesiastical judges of so high authority as
the bishops by whose sentence the innocence of Cæcilianus and their own guilt had been
declared. He granted them the second trial at Aries, before other bishops; not because this
was due to them, but only as a concession to their stubbornness, and from a desire by all
means to restrain so great effrontery. For this Christian Emperor did not presume so to
grant their unruly and groundless complaints as to make himself the judge of the decision
pronounced by the bishops who had sat at Rome; but he appointed, as I have said, other
bishops, from whom, however, they preferred again to appeal to the Emperor himself; and
you have heard the terms in which he disapproved of this. Would that even then they had
desisted from their most insane contentions, and had yielded at last to the truth, as he yielded
to them when (intending afterwards to apologize for this course to the reverend prelates)
he consented to try their case after the bishops, on condition that, if they did not submit to
his decision, for which they had themselves appealed, they should thenceforward be silent!
For he ordered that both parties should meet him at Rome to argue the case. When Cæcili-
anus, for some reason, failed to compear there, he, at their request, ordered all to follow him
to Milan. Then some of their party began to withdraw, perhaps offended that Constantine
did not follow their example, and condemn Cæcilianus in his absence at once and summarily.
When the prudent Emperor was aware of this, he compelled the rest to come to Milan in
charge of his guards. Cæcilianus having come thither, he brought him forward in person,
as he has written; and having examined the matter with the diligence, caution, and prudence
which his letters on the subject indicate, he pronounced Cæcilianus perfectly innocent, and
them most criminal.
Chap. VIII.
21. And to this day they administer baptism outside of the communion of the Church,
283
and, if they can, they rebaptize the members of the Church: they offer sacrifice in discord
and schism, and salute in the name of peace communities which they pronounce beyond
the bounds of the peace of salvation. The unity of Christ is rent asunder, the heritage of
Christ is reproached, the baptism of Christ is treated with contempt; and they refuse to have
these errors corrected by constituted human authorities, applying penalties of a temporal
kind in order to prevent them from being doomed to eternal punishment for such sacrilege.
641
To Glorius, Eleusius, etc.