Excursus on Pelagianism.
The only point which is material to the main object of this volume is that Pelagius and
his fellow heretic Celestius were condemned by the Ecumenical Council of Ephesus for their
heresy. On this point there can be no possible doubt. And further than this the Seventh
Council by ratifying the Canons of Trullo received the Canons of the African Code which
include those of the Carthaginian conciliar condemnations of the Pelagian heresy to which
the attention of the reader is particularly drawn. The condemnation of these heretics at
Ephesus is said to have been due chiefly to the energy of St. Augustine, assisted very mater-
ially by a layman living in Constantinople by the name of Marius Mercator.
Pelagius and his heresy have a sad interest to us as he is said to have been born in Britain.
He was a monk and preached at Rome with great applause in the early years of the fifth
century. But in his extreme horror of Manichæism and Gnosticism he fell into the opposite
extreme; and from the hatred of the doctrine of the inherent evilness of humanity he fell
into the error of denying the necessity of grace.
Pelagius’s doctrines may be briefly stated thus. Adam’s sin injured only himself, so that
there is no such thing as original sin. Infants therefore are not born in sin and the children
of wrath, but are born innocent, and only need baptism so as to be knit into Christ, not “for
the remission of sins” as is declared in the creed. Further he taught that man could live
without committing any sin at all. And for this there was no need of grace; indeed grace
was not possible, according to his teaching. The only “grace,” which he would admit the
existence of, was what we may call external grace, e.g. the example of Christ, the teaching
of his ministers, and the like. Petavius265 indeed thinks that he allowed the activity of in-
ternal grace to illumine the intellect, but this seems quite doubtful.
Pelagius’s writings have come down to us in a more or less—generally the latter—pure
form. There are fourteen books on the Epistles of St. Paul, also a letter to Demetrius and
his Libellus fidei ad Innocentium. In the writings of St. Augustine are found fragments of
Pelagius’s writings on free will.
It would be absurd to attempt in the limits possible to this volume to give any, even the
most sketchy, treatment of the doctrine involved in the Pelagian controversy: the reader
must be referred to the great theologians for this and to aid him I append a bibliographical
table on the subject.
St. Augustine.
St. Jerome.
Marius Mercator, Commonitorium super nomine Cœlestii.
Vossius, G. J., Histor. de controv. quas Pel. ejusque reliquiæ moverunt.
265 Petav. De Pelag. et Semi-Pelag. Hær., Cap. iv.
Excursus on Pelagianism.
433
Excursus on Pelagianism.