3. Matthias,207 also, who was numbered with the apostles in the place of Judas, and the
one who was honored by being made a candidate with him,208 are likewise said to have been
deemed worthy of the same calling with the seventy. They say that Thaddeus209 also was
one of them, concerning whom I shall presently relate an account which has come down to
us.210 And upon examination you will find that our Saviour had more than seventy disciples,
according to the testimony of Paul, who says that after his resurrection from the dead he
appeared first to Cephas, then to the twelve, and after them to above five hundred brethren
at once, of whom some had fallen asleep;211 but the majority were still living at the time he
wrote.
4. Afterwards he says he appeared unto James, who was one of the so-called brethren
of the Saviour.212 But, since in addition to these, there were many others who were called
207 We learn from Acts i. 21 sqq. that Matthias was a follower of Christ throughout his ministry and therefore
the tradition, which Eusebius is, so far as we know, the first to record, is not at all improbable. Epiphanius (at
the close of the first book of his Hær., Dindorf’s ed. I. p. 337) a half-century later records the same tradition.
Nicephorus Callistus (II. 40) says that he labored and suffered martyrdom in Ethiopia (probably meaning
Caucasian Ethiopia, east of the Black Sea). Upon the Gospel of Matthias see below, III. 25, note 30.
208 Joseph Barsabas, surnamed Justus. He, too, had been with Christ from the beginning, and therefore may
well have been one of the Seventy, as Eusebius reports. Papias (quoted by Eusebius, III. 39, below) calls him
Justus Barsabas, and relates that he drank a deadly poison without experiencing any injury.
209 From a comparison of the different lists of apostles given by Matthew, Mark, and Luke, Thaddeus is seen
to be one of the Twelve, apparently identical with Jude and Lebbæus (compare Jerome, In Matt. X.). Eusebius
here sunders him from the apostles and makes him one of the Seventy, committing an error similar to that
which arose in the case of Peter and Cephas. He perhaps records only an oral tradition, as he uses the word
φασί. He is, so far as is known, the first to mention the tradition.
210 See the next chapter.
211 See 1 Cor. xv. 5–7.
212 The relationship of James and Jesus has always been a disputed matter. Three theories have been advanced,
and are all widely represented. The first is the full-brother hypothesis, according to which the brothers and sisters
of Jesus were children of both Joseph and Mary. This was advocated strongly by the heretic Helvidius in Rome
in 380, and is widely accepted in the Protestant Church. The only serious objection to it is the committal of
Mary to the care of John by Christ upon the cross. But John was at any rate an own cousin of Jesus, and the ob-
jection loses its weight when we realize the spiritual sympathy which existed between Jesus and John, and the
lack of belief exhibited by his own brothers. The second is the half-brother hypothesis which regards the brethren
and sisters of Jesus as children of Joseph by a former wife. This has the oldest tradition in its favor (though the
tradition for none of the theories is old or universal enough to be of great weight), the apocryphal Gospel of
James, chap. ix., recording that Joseph was a widower and had children before marrying Mary. It is still the es-
tablished theory in the Greek Church. The greatest objection to it is that if it be true, Christ as a younger son of
Joseph, could not have been regarded as the heir to the throne of David. That the objection is absolutely fatal
155
The Disciples of our Saviour.