CHAP. IX.] DO THE VIRTUES EXIST IN THE LIFE TO COME ? 359
it will have left in the memory: as has been already said
above.
Chap. ix.—Whetherjustice and the other virtues cease to exist in the
future life.
12. There is, however, some question raised, whether the
virtues likewise by which one lives well in this present mor-
tality, seeing that they themselves begin also to be in the
mind, which was a mind none the less when it existed before
without them, cease also to exist at that time when they have
brought us to things eternal. For some have thought that
they will cease, and in the case of three—prudence, fortitude,
temperance—such an assertion seems to have something in it
;
but justice is immortal, and will rather then be made perfect
in us than cease to be. Yet Tullius, the great author of
eloquence, when arguing in the dialogue Hortensius, says of all
four : " If we were allowed, when we migrated from this life,
to live for ever in the islands of the blessed, as fables tell,
what need were there of eloquence when there would be no
trials, or what need, indeed, of the very virtues themselves ?
For we should not need fortitude when nothing of either toil
or danger was proposed to us ; nor justice, when there was
nothing of anybody else's to be coveted ; nor temperance, to
govern lusts that would not exist ; nor, indeed, should we need
prudence, when there was no choice offered between good and
evil. We should be blessed, therefore, solely by learning and
Imowing nature, by which alone also the life of the gods is
praiseworthy. And hence we may perceive that everything
else is a matter of necessity, but this is one of free choice."
This great orator, then, when proclaiming the excellence of
philosophy, going over again all that he had learned from
philosophers, and excellently and pleasantly explaining it, has
affirmed all four virtues to be necessary in this life only, which
we see to be full of troubles and mistakes ; but not one of
them when we shall have migrated from this life, if we are
permitted to live there where is a blessed life; but that
blessed souls are blessed only in learning and knowing, i.e. in
the contemplation of nature, than which nothing is better
and more lovable. It is that nature which created and
appointed all other natures. And if it belongs to justice to be