150 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK V.
other Son, according to substance. But because the Father is
not called the Father except in that He has a Son, and the
Son is not called Son except in that He has a Father, these
things are not said according to substance ; because each of
them is not so called in relation to Himself, but the terms are
used reciprocally and in relation each to the other ; nor yet
according to accident, because both the being called the
Father, and the being called the Son, is eternal and unchange-
able to them. Wherefore, although to be the Father and to
be the Son is different, yet their substance is not different
;
because they are so called, not according to substance, but
according to relation, which relation, however, is not accident,
because it is not changeable.
Chap. vi.—Reply is made to the cavils ofthe heretics in respect to the same
words begotten and unhegotten.
7. But if they think they can answer this reasoning thus,
—
that the Father indeed is so called in relation to the Son, and
the Son in relation to the Father, but that they are said to be
unbegotten and begotten in relation to themselves, not in
relation each to the other ; for that it is not the same thing
to call Him unbegotten as it is to call Him the Father,
because there would be nothing to hinder our calling Him
unbegotten even if He had not begotten the Son ; and if any
one beget a son, he is not therefore himself unbegotten, for men,
who are begotten by other men, themselves also beget others
;
and therefore they say the Father is called Father in relation
to the Son, and the Son is called Son in relation to the Father,
but unbegotten is said in relation to Himself, and begotten
in relation to Himself; and therefore, if whatever is said in
relation to oneself is said according to substance, while to be
unbegotten and to be begotten are different, then the substance
is different
:
—if this is what they say, then they do not under-
stand that they do indeed say something that requires more
careful discussion in respect to the term unbegotten, because
neither is any one therefore a father because unbegotten, nor
therefore unbegotten because he is a father, and on that account
he is supposed to be called unbegotten, not in relation to any-
thing else, but in respect to himself; but, on the other hand,
with a wonderful blindness, they do not perceive that no one