Tymion,1622 small towns in Phrygia, Jerusalem, wishing to gather people to them from all
directions; who appointed collectors of money;1623 who contrived the receiving of gifts
under the name of offerings; who provided salaries for those who preached his doctrine,
that its teaching might prevail through gluttony.”1624
Church; and the regulations for these two weeks were made very severe. Still further they extended the duration
of the regular weekly (Wednesday and Friday) fasts, making them cover the whole instead of only a part of the
day. The Catholics very strenuously opposed these ordinances, not because they were opposed to fasting (many
of them indulged extensively in the practice), but because they objected to the imposition of such extra fasts as
binding upon the Church. They were satisfied with the traditional customs in this matter, and did not care to
have heavier burdens imposed upon the Christians in general than their fathers had borne. Our principal sources
for a knowledge of the dispute between the Montanists and Catholics on this subject are Tertullian’s de Jejuniis;
Epiphanius, Hær. XLVIII. 8; Jerome, Ep. ad Marcellam (Migne, Ep. XLI. 3), Comment. in Matt. c. 9, vers. 15;
and Theodoret, Hær. Fab. III. 2.
1622 Pepuza was an obscure town in the western part of Phrygia; Tymion, otherwise unknown, was probably
situated in the same neighborhood. Pepuza was early made, and long continued, the chief center—the Jerus-
alem—of the sect, and even gave its name to the sect in many quarters. Harnack has rightly emphasized the
significance of this statement of Apollonius, and has called attention to the fact that Montanus’ original idea
must have been the gathering of the chosen people from all the world into one region, that they might form one
fold, and freed from all the political and social relations in which they had hitherto lived might await the coming
of the Lord, who would speedily descend, and set up his kingdom in this new Jerusalem. Only after this idea
had been proved impracticable did Montanism adapt itself to circumstances and proceed to establish itself in
the midst of society as it existed in the outside world. That Montanus built upon the Gospel of John, and especially
upon chaps. x. and xvii., in this original attempt of his, is perfectly plain (cf. Harnack’s Dogmengeschichte, I. p.
319 and 323. With this passage from Apollonius, compare also Epiphanius, Hær. XLVIII. 14 and XLIX. 1., and
Jerome Ep. ad Marcellam).
1623 This appointment of economic officers and the formation of a compact organization were a part of the
one general plan, referred to in the previous note, and must have marked the earliest years of the sect. Later,
when it was endeavoring to adapt itself to the catholic Church, and to compromise matters in such a way as still
to secure recognition from the Church, this organization must have been looked upon as a matter of less import-
ance, and indeed probably never went far beyond the confines of Phrygia. That it continued long in that region,
however, is clear from Jerome’s words in his Epistle to Marcella already referred to. Compare also chap 16, note
25.
1624 There can be little doubt that the Church teachers and other officers were still supported by voluntary
contributions, and hence Apollonius was really scandalized at what he considered making merchandise of
spiritual things (cf. the Didache, chaps. XI. and XII.; but even in the Didache we find already a sort of stated
salary provided for the prophets; cf. chap. XII.). For him to conclude, however, from the practice instituted by
the Montanists in accordance with their other provisions for the formation of a compact organization, that they
558
The Manner in which Apollonius refuted the Phrygians, and the Persons whom…