writing led and obliged me to maintain that position or doctrine of mine, which was the
occasion of this debate.
And be it so, that I did suppose this position was contrary to Mr. Stoddard’s opinion,
and was opposed by him, 381 and therefore thought fit in my Preface to excuse myself to the
world for differing from him; did this oblige me, in all that I wrote for maintaining my pos-
ition, to keep myself strictly to the words which he had expressed his question in, and to
regulate and limit myself in every argument I used, and objection I answered, by the terms
which he made use of in proposing his opinion and arguments? And if I have not done it,
do I therefore deserve to be charged before the world with changing the question, with unfair
treatment of Mr. Stoddard, with surprisingly going off from his argument, with disserving the
cause of truth, &c.
It would have been no great condescension in Mr. W. if he had allowed that I knew
488
what the question was, which was disputed between me and my people, as well as he, in a
distant part of the country. Yea, if he had acknowledged, that I was as likely as he, to under-
stand Mr. Stoddard’s real sentiments and practice; since I was in the ministry two years with
him, as co-pastor of the same church, and was united with him in ecclesiastical administra-
tions, in admitting members, and in examining them as to their qualifications. I have stood
for more than twenty-three years in a pastoral relation to his church, most intimately ac-
quainted with the nature of its constitution, its sentiments and method of administration,
and all its religious concerns. I have myself been immediately concerned in the admission
of more than three quarters of its present members, and have had the greatest occasion to
look into their way of admission, and have been acquainted with every living member that
Mr. S. had admitted before my coming; and have been particularly informed, by many of
them, of the manner of Mr. S—d’s conduct in admitting them, their own apprehensions
concerning the terms of their admission, and the profession they made in order to it; and
also the sentiments of the whole of that large town, who were born and brought up under
his ministry, concerning his constant doctrine and practice, relating to the admission of
members, from their infancy.—Whereas, Mr. W. from his youth had lived in another part
of the country, at seventy miles distance.
381 Whether I was mistaken in this, will appear in the sequel.
1902
SECTION I. What is the question?