bishops; in which Council, after seventy-five days of deliberation, all past decisions on the
matter being set aside, a carefully revised resolution was published, to the effect that to those
who were guilty of a heinous crime as traditors, the privilege of communion should be
granted as to blameless persons, if they refused to be baptized. He says further, that Deuterius
of Macriana, a bishop of your party, added to the Church a whole crowd of traditors, without
making any distinction between them and others, making the unity of the Church open to
these traditors, in accordance with the decree of the Council held by these two hundred and
seventy of your bishops, and that after that transaction Donatus continued unbroken his
communion with the said Deuterius, and not only with him, but also with all the Mauritanian
bishops for forty years, who, according to the statement of Tychonius, admitted the traditors
to communion without insisting on their being rebaptized, up to the time of the persecution
made by Macarius.
44. You will say, “What has that Tychonius to do with me?” It is true that Tychonius is
the man whom Parmenianus checked by his reply, and effectually warned not to write such
things; but he did not refute the statements themselves, but, as I have said above, silenced
him by this one thing, that while saying such things concerning the Church which is diffused
throughout the world, and while admitting that the faults of other men within its unity
cannot defile one who is innocent, he nevertheless withdrew himself from the contagion of
communion with African Christians because of their being traditors, and was an adherent
of the party of Donatus. Parmenianus, indeed, might have said that Tychonius had in all
these things spoken falsely; but, as Tychonius himself observes, many were still living at that
time by whom these things might be proved to be most unquestionably true and generally
known.
45. Of these things, however, I say no more: maintain, if you choose, that Tychonius
spoke falsely; I bring you back to Cyprian, the authority which you yourself have quoted.
If, according to his writings, every one in the unity of the Church is defiled by the sins of
other members, then the Church had utterly perished before Cyprian’s time, and all possib-
ility of Cyprian’s own existence (as a member of the Church) is taken away. If, however, the
very thought of this is impiety, and it be beyond question that the Church continued in being,
it follows that no one is defiled by the guilt of the sins of other men within the Catholic
unity; and in vain do you, “an evil generation,” maintain that you are righteous, when you
are “not washed from the guilt of your going forth.”
Chap. XI.
46. You will say, “Why then do you seek us? Why do you receive those whom you call
heretics?” Mark how simple and short is my reply. We seek you because you are lost, that
874
To Vincentius