This canon (which in the Prisca and the Isidorian version stands as part of canon 11)
deals, like it, with cases which had arisen under the Eastern reign of Licinius, who having
resolved to “purge his army of all ardent Christians” (Mason, Persec. of Diocl. p. 308), ordered
his Christian officers to sacrifice to the gods on pain of being cashiered (compare Euseb. H.
E. x. 8; Vit. Con. i. 54). It is to be observed here that military life as such was not deemed
unchristian. The case of Cornelius was borne in mind. “We serve in your armies,” says
Tertullian, Apol. 42 (although later, as a Montanist, he took a rigorist and fanatical view, De
Cor. 11), and compare the fact which underlies the tale of the “Thundering Legion,”—the
presence of Christians in the army of Marcus Aurelius. It was the heathenish adjuncts to
their calling which often brought Christian soldiers to a stand (see Routh. Scr. Opusc. i. 410),
as when Marinus’ succession to a centurionship was challenged on the ground that he could
not sacrifice to the gods (Euseb. H. E. vii. 15). Sometimes, indeed, individual Christians
thought like Maximilian in the Martyrology, who absolutely refused to enlist, and on being
told by the proconsul that there were Christian soldiers in the imperial service, answered,
“Ipsi sciunt quod ipsis expediat” (Ruinart, Act. Sanc. p. 341). But, says Bingham (Antiq. xi.
5, 10), “the ancient canons did not condemn the military life as a vocation simply unlawful.…I
believe there is no instance of any man being refused baptism merely because he was a soldier,
unless some unlawful circumstance, such as idolatry, or the like, made the vocation sinful.”
After the victory of Constantine in the West, the Council of Arles excommunicated those
who in time of peace “threw away their arms” (can. 2). In the case before us, some Christian
officers had at first stood firm under the trial imposed on them by Licinius. They had been
“called by grace” to an act of self-sacrifice (the phrase is one which St. Augustine might have
used); and had shown “their eagerness at the outset” (“primum suum ardorem,” Dionysius;
Philo and Evarestus more laxly, “primordia bona;” compare τὴν ἀγάπην σου τὴν πρώτην,
Rev. ii. 4). Observe here how beautifully the ideas of grace and free will are harmonized.
These men had responded to a Divine impulse: it might seem that they had committed
themselves to a noble course: they had cast aside the “belts” which were their badge of office
(compare the cases of Valentinian and Valens, Soc. iii. 13, and of Benevolus throwing down
his belt at the feet of Justina, Soz. vii. 13). They had done, in fact, just what Auxentius, one
of Licinius’ notaries, had done when, according to the graphic anecdote of Philostorgius
(Fragm. 5), his master bade him place a bunch of grapes before a statue of Bacchus in the
palace-court; but their zeal, unlike his, proved to be too impulsive—they reconsidered their
29
position, and illustrated the maxim that in morals second thoughts are not best (Butler,
Serm. 7), by making unworthy attempts—in some cases by bribery—to recover what they
had worthily resigned. (Observe the Grecised Latinism βενεφικίοις and compare the Latin-
isms of St. Mark, and others in Euseb. iii. 20, vi. 40, x. 5.) This the Council describes in
proverbial language, probably borrowed from 2 Pet. ii. 22, but, it is needless to say, without
intending to censure enlistment as such. They now desired to be received to penance: ac-
85
Canon XII.