when the apostle directs persons to try themselves with respect to their qualifications for
the Lord’s supper, he would not have them come, if upon trial they find themselves not
qualified. But it would be ridiculous to say, that I therefore suppose the meaning of the
word, try or examine, is to approve, when it is evident that the trying is only in order to
knowing whether a thing is to be approved, or disapproved.
In p. 98. b. on the argument from John’s baptism, Mr. W. alters my words, bringing
them the better to comport with the odious representation he had made of my opinion, viz.
that I required giving an account of experiences, as a term of communion; he puts in words
as mine which are not mine, and distinguishes them with marks of quotation; charging me
with representing it as ” probable that John had as much time to inquire into their experiences
as into their doctrinal knowledge.”—Whereas, my words are these, (p. 101. a.) He had as
much opportunity to inquire info the credibility of their profession, as he had to inquire into
their doctrinal knowledge and moral character.
In p. 118. d. (and to the like purpose, p. 134. c.) our author represents me, and others
of my principles, as holding, That the gospel does peremptorily sentence men to damnation
for eating and drinking without sanctifying grace. But surely Mr. W. would have done well
to have referred to the place in my Inquiry, where any thing is said that has such an appear-
ance. For, I find nothing that I have said in that book, or any other writing of mine, about
the gospel peremptorily sentencing such men to damnation, or signifying how far I thought
they were exposed to damnation, or expressing my sentiments more or less about the matter.
In p. 130. e. and 131. a. Mr. W. says, ” When one sees with what epithets of honour Mr.
Edwards in some parts of his book has complimented Mr. Stoddard, it must look like a
strange medley to tack to them;—That he was a weak beggar of his question; a supposer of
what was to be proved; taking for granted the point in controversy; inconsistent with himself;
ridiculously contradicting his own arguments.” These expressions, which Mr. W. speaks of
as tacked to those honourable epithets, he represents as expressions which I had used con-
cerning Mr. Stoddard. And his readers that have not consulted my book, will doubtless take
it so from his manner of representation. Whereas, the truth is, no one of these expressions
is used concerning Mr. S. any where in my book; nor is there one disrespectful word spoken
of him there. All the ground Mr. W. had to make such a representation, was, that in answering
arguments against my opinion I endeavoured to show them to be weak, (though I do not
find that I used that epithet,) and certainly for one to pretend to answer arguments, and yet
allow them to be strong, would be to show himself to be very weak. In answering some of
these arguments, and endeavouring to show wherein the inconclusiveness of them lay, I
have sometimes taken notice that the defect lay in what is called begging the question, or
supposing the thing to be proved. And if I had said so concerning Mr. S—d’s arguments,
speaking of them as his, I do not know why it should be represented as any personal reflection,
or unhandsome dishonourable treatment of him. Every inconclusive argument is weak; and
1970
SECTION I. Method of disputing.