Excursus on the Reception of the Seventh Council.
The reception of the Seventh Council in the East was practically universal. No historian
pretends that the iconoclastic opinions had any hold over the masses of the people. It was
strictly speaking a court movement, backed by the army, and whenever the images were
laid low and their veneration condemned it was by the power of the State, enforcing its will
upon a yielding and (as we would call them to-day) Erastian clergy. (Cf. Harnack, History
of Dogma, Eng. tr. Vol. iv., p. 326.)
The struggle indeed was not quite put an end to by the conciliar decree. After the death
576
of the Empress in a.d. 803, several iconoclastic rulers sat on the throne of the East, among
them Michael the Stammerer, who (as Michaud wittily says) “fought the images and married
the nuns.”546 He sent a letter, which is still extant, to Louis le Débonnaire of France, setting
forth the superstitions of the orthodox, which is most curious and interesting reading. (Vide
Mansi.)
His successor was Theophilus, who reigned from 829 until 842, and was a fanatical
iconoclast. The Patriarchs of Antioch, Alexandria, and Jerusalem wrote to him officially,
several years after his accession, begging him not to imitate the bad example of the icono-
clasts. At that time the only Patriarch who sided with the heretics was John the Grammarian,
the Patriarch of Constantinople, the very same who in 814 had repudiated the iconoclast
doctrine! With the death of this Emperor, the power of the Iconoclasts likewise died; and
at the accession of Michael III with his mother Theodora and his sister Thecla came the final
triumph of the images. I shall quote here the words of Harnack: “Then came an Empress,
Theodora, who finally restored the worship. This took place at the Synod held at Con-
stantinople a.d. 842. This Synod decreed that a Feast of Orthodoxy (ἡ κυριακὴ τῆς
ὀρθοδοξίας ) should be celebrated annually, at which the victory over the iconoclasts should
be regularly remembered. Thus the whole of orthodoxy was united in image-worship. In
this way the Eastern Church reached the position which suited its nature. We have here
the conclusion of a development, consistent in the main points. The divine and sacred, as
that had descended into the sensuous world by the incarnation, had created for itself in the
546 It was during this period that St. Theodore, writing in 826 to Arsenius, observes: “Rome has not received
it as an Ecumenical Council, but only as a provincial Synod, assembled to remedy a particular evil; Legates of
the other Patriarchs were not there; those of Rome had come on different business: Legates, indeed, there were
from the East, but they were brought by our deputies, not sent by their Patriarchs, who knew nothing of the
matter till afterwards. Our countrymen acted thus for the purpose of more easily bringing back the heretics by
persuading them that it was an Œcumenical Council.” “Theodore, however, it is fair to add, afterwards changed
his opinion.” Such is Dr. Neale’s candid admission. Hist. of the East. Ch., Vol. II., p. 135. How often, alas! has
this passage been quoted by controversialists, and the word of warning to the reader been wholly omitted.
Excursus on the Reception of the Seventh Council.
1063
Excursus on the Reception of the Seventh Council.