Chapter X.—The Manner in which Josephus mentions the Divine Books.
1. 675“We have not, therefore, a multitude of books disagreeing and conflicting with
one another; but we have only twenty-two, which contain the record of all time and are
justly held to be divine.
675 Against Apion, I. 8. The common Christian tradition (since the first century, when it was stated in the
fourth book of Ezra xiv. 44 sq.) is that Ezra was the compiler of the Old Testament canon. This, however, is a
mistake, for the canon was certainly not completed before the time of Judas Maccabæus. Josephus is the earliest
writer to give us a summary of the books of the Old Testament; and he evidently gives not merely his own private
opinion but the commonly accepted canon of his day. He does not name the separate books, but he tells us that
they were twenty-two in number (the number of the letters of the Hebrew alphabet), and gives us the three di-
visions, so that we are able to ascertain his canon in detail. It was doubtless as follows:— 1–5. Books of Moses.
6. Joshua. 7. Judges and Ruth. 8. Samuel. 9. Kings. 10. Chronicles. 11. Ezra and Nehemiah. 12. Esther. 13. Isaiah.
14. Jeremiah and Lamentations. 15. Ezekiel. 16. Daniel. 17. Twelve Minor Prophets. 18. Job. 19. Psalms. 20.
Proverbs. 21. Ecclesiastes. 22. Song of Songs. The earliest detailed list of Old Testament books is that of Melito
(given by Eusebius, IV. 26), which is as follows:— Books of Moses Genesis. Exodus. Leviticus. Numbers. Deu-
teronomy. Joshua Nave. Judges. Ruth. Four of Kings. Chronicles. Psalms. Proverbs. Ecclesiastes. Song of Songs.
Job. Isaiah. Jeremiah. Twelve Minor Prophets. Daniel. Ezekiel. Ezra. Melito says nothing of the number twenty-
two, and, in fact, his list, as he gives it, numbers only twenty-one. His list really differs from Josephus’ only in
omitting the Book of Esther. This omission may be accidental, though it is omitted by Athanasius and Gregory
Nazianzen. He makes no mention of Nehemiah, but that is doubtless included with Ezra, as in the case of
Josephus’ canon. His canon purports to be the Palestinian one, and hence we should expect it to be the same as
that of Josephus, which makes it more probable that the omission of Esther was only accidental. Origen (in
Eusebius, VI. 25) tells us that there were twenty-two books in the Hebrew canon; but his list differs somewhat
from that of Josephus. It is as follows:— 1–5. Books of Moses. 6. Joshua. 7. Judges and Ruth. 8. Samuel. 9. Kings.
10. Chronicles. 11. Ezra I. and II. 12. Psalms. 13. Proverbs. 14. Ecclesiastes. 15. Song of Songs. 16. [Twelve Minor
Prophets (Rufinus).] 17. Isaiah. 18. Jeremiah, Lamentations, and Epistle. 19. Daniel. 20. Ezekiel. 21. Job. 22. Es-
ther. “Besides these also the Maccabees.” The peculiar thing about the list is the omission of the Twelve Minor
Prophets and the insertion of the Epistle of Jeremiah. The former were certainly looked upon by Origen as sacred
books, for he wrote a commentary upon them (according to Eusebius, VI. 36). There is no conceivable reason
for their omission, and indeed they are needed to make up the number twenty-two. We must conclude that the
omission was simply an oversight on the part of Eusebius or of some transcriber. Rufinus gives them as number
sixteen, as shown in the list, but the position there assigned to them is not the ordinary one. We should expect
to find them in connection with the other prophets; but the various lists are by no means uniform in the order
of the books. On the other hand, the Greek Epistle of Jeremiah (Baruch vi.) did not stand in the Hebrew canon,
and can have been included by Origen here only because he had been used to seeing it in connection with
Jeremiah in his copy of the LXX. (for in ancient mss. of the LXX., which probably represent the original arrange-
ment, it is given not as a part of Baruch, but as an appendix to Lamentations), and hence mentioned it in this
book without thinking of its absence from the Hebrew canon. Origen adds the Maccabees to his list, but expressly
The Manner in which Josephus mentions the Divine Books.
284
The Manner in which Josephus mentions the Divine Books.