render them subject to criticism, when his own voice acknowledges the absurdity of his
doctrine. His words stand as follows:—“What? did not earth and angel come into being,
when before they were not?” See how our lofty theologian is not ashamed to apply the same
description to earth and angels and to the Maker of all! Surely if he thinks it fit to predicate
the same of earth and its Lord, he must either make a god of the one, or degrade the other
to a level with it.
Then he adds to this something by which his profanity is yet more completely stripped
238
of all disguise, so that its absurdity is obvious even to a child. For he says,—“It would be a
long task to detail all the modes of generation of intelligible objects, or the essences which
do not all possess the nature of the Existent in common, but display variations according
to the operations of Him Who constructed them.” Without any words of ours, the blasphemy
against the Son which is here contained is glaring and conspicuous, when he acknowledges
that that which is predicated of every mode of generation and essence in nowise differs from
the description of the Divine subsistence1011 of the Only-begotten. But it seems to me best
to pass over the intermediate passages in which he seeks to maintain his profanity, and to
hasten to the head and front of the accusation which we have to bring against his doctrines.
For he will be found to exhibit the sacrament of regeneration as an idle thing, the mystic
oblation as profitless, and the participation in them as of no advantage to those who are
partakers therein. For after those high-wrought æons1012 in which, by way of disparagement
of our doctrine, he names as its supporters a Valentinus, a Cerinthus, a Basilides, a Montanus,
and a Marcion, and after laying it down that those who affirm that the Divine nature is un-
knowable, and the mode of His generation unknowable, have no right or title whatever to
the name of Christians, and after reckoning us among those whom he thus disparages, he
proceeds to develop his own view in these terms:—“But we, in agreement with holy and
blessed men; affirm that the mystery of godliness does not consist in venerable names, nor
in the distinctive character of customs and sacramental tokens, but in exactness of doctrine.”
That when he wrote this, he did so not under the guidance of evangelists, apostles, or any
of the authors of the Old Testament, is plain to every one who has any acquaintance with
the sacred and Divine Scripture. We should naturally be led to suppose that by “holy and
blessed men” he meant Manichæus, Nicolaus, Colluthus, Aetius, Arius, and the rest of the
same band, with whom he is in strict accord in laying down this principle, that neither the
confession of sacred names, nor the customs of the Church, nor her sacramental tokens,
are a ratification of godliness. But we, having learnt from the holy voice of Christ that “except
a man be born again of water and of the Spirit he shall not enter into the kingdom of God1013”
1011 ὑποστασέως
1012 The word seems to be used, as “octads” in Book IX. seems to be used, of sections of Eunomius’ production.
1013 Cf. S. John iii. 3 and 6.
454
Eunomius again speaks of the Son as Lord and God, and Maker of all creation…