Chapter 1.—1. Being able to read, Petilianus, I have read your letter, in which you have
shown with sufficient clearness that, in supporting the party of Donatus against the Catholic
Church, you have neither been able to say anything to the purpose, nor been allowed to
hold your tongue. What violent emotions did you endure, what a storm of feelings surged
within your heart, on reading the answer which I made, with all possible brevity and clearness,
to that portion of your letter which alone at that time had come into my hands! For you
saw that the truth which we maintain and defend was confirmed with such strength of ar-
gument, and illustrated with such abundant light, that you could not find anything which
could be said against it, whereby the charges which we make might be refuted. You observed,
also, that the attention of many who had read it was fixed on you, since they desired to know
what you would say, what you would do, how you would escape from the difficulty, how
you would make your way out of the strait in which the word of God had encompassed you.
Hereupon you, when you ought to have shown contempt for the opinion of the foolish ones,
and to have gone on to adopt sound and truthful sentiments, preferred rather to do what
Scripture has foretold of men like you: "Thou hast loved evil more than good, and lying
rather than to speak righteousness."2320 Just as if I in turn were willing to recompense unto
you railing for railing; in which case, what should we be but two evil speakers, so that those
who read our words would either preserve their self-respect by throwing us aside with ab-
horrence, or eagerly devour what we wrote to gratify their malice? For my own part, since
I answer every one, whether in writing or by word of mouth, even when I have been attacked
with insulting accusations, in such language as the Lord puts in my mouth, restraining and
crushing the stings of empty indignation in the interests of my hearer or reader, I do not
strive to prove myself superior to my adversary by abusing him, but rather to be a source
of health in him by convicting him of his error.
2. For if those who take into consideration what you have written have any feelings
whatsoever, how did it serve you in the cause which is at issue between us respecting the
Catholic communion and the party of Donatus, that, leaving a matter which was in a certain
sense of public interest, you should have been led by private animosity to attack the life of
an individual with malicious revilings, just as though that individual were the question in
debate? Did you think so badly, I do not say of Christians, but of the whole human race, as
not to suppose that your writings might come into the hands of some prudent men, who
would lay aside all thoughts of individuals like us, and inquire rather into the question which
was at issue between us, and pay heed, not to who and what we were, but to what we might
be able to advance in defense of the truth or against error? You should have paid respect
to these men’s judgment, you should have guarded yourself against their censure, lest they
should think that you could find nothing to say, unless you set before yourself some one
2320 Ps. lii. 3.
Chapter 1
1182
Chapter 1