Chapter
XLVI.
But how can this Jew of Celsus escape the charge of
falsehood, when he says that Jesus, “when on earth, gained over
to himself only ten sailors and tax-gatherers of the most worthless
character, and not even the whole of these?” Now it is
certain that the Jews themselves would admit that He drew over not ten
persons merely, nor a hundred, nor a thousand, but on one occasion five
thousand at once, and on another four thousand; and that He attracted
them to such a degree that they followed Him even into the deserts,
which alone could contain the assembled multitude of those who believed
in God through Jesus, and where He not only addressed to them
discourses, but also manifested to them His works. And now,
through his tautology, he compels us also to be tautological, since we
are careful to guard against being supposed to pass over any of the
charges advanced by him; and therefore, in reference to the matter
before us following the order of his treatise as we have it, he
says: “Is it not the height of absurdity to maintain, that
if, while he himself was alive, he won over not a single person to his
views, after his death any who wish are able to gain over such a
multitude of individuals?” Whereas he ought to have said,
in consistency with truth, that if, after His death, not simply those
who will, but they who have the will and the power, can gain over so
many proselytes, how much more consonant to reason is it, that while He
was alive He should, through the greater power of His words and deeds,
have won over to Himself manifold greater numbers of
adherents?